A piston of mass M is hung from a massless spring whose restoring force law goes as F = -kx, where k is the spring constant of appropriate dimension. The piston separates the vertical chamber into two parts, where the bottom part is filled with 'n' moles of an ideal gas. An external work is done on the gas isothermally (at a constant temperature T) with the help of a heating filament (with negligible volume) mounted in lower part of the chamber, so that the piston goes up from a height $ L_0 $ to $ L_1 $, the total energy delivered by the filament is (Assume spring to be in its natural length before heating)
A piston of mass M is hung from a massless spring whose restoring force law goes as F = -kx, where k is the spring constant of appropriate dimension. The piston separates the vertical chamber into two parts, where the bottom part is filled with 'n' moles of an ideal gas. An external work is done on the gas isothermally (at a constant temperature T) with the help of a heating filament (with negligible volume) mounted in lower part of the chamber, so that the piston goes up from a height $ L_0 $ to $ L_1 $, the total energy delivered by the filament is (Assume spring to be in its natural length before heating)
Show Hint
- \( 3nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + 2Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \frac{k}{3} (L_1^3 - L_0^3) \)
- \( nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + \frac{Mg}{2} (L_1 - L_0) + \frac{k}{4} (L_1^4 - L_0^4) \)
- \( nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \frac{k}{4} (L_1^4 - L_0^4) \)
- \( nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \frac{3k}{4} (L_1^4 - L_0^4) \)
The Correct Option is C
Approach Solution - 1
The question asks for the total energy delivered by the filament, which is the heat supplied to the gas, \( \Delta Q \).
Step 1: Apply the First Law of Thermodynamics.
The process is isothermal, so \( \Delta T = 0 \). For an ideal gas, this means the change in internal energy \( \Delta U = 0 \). From the First Law of Thermodynamics, \( \Delta Q = \Delta U + W_{gas} \), we get:
\[ \Delta Q = W_{gas} \]
So, we need to find the work done by the gas during its expansion.
Step 2: Calculate the work done by the gas using thermodynamics.
The gas expands from an initial height \( L_0 \) to a final height \( L_1 \). If the piston has a cross-sectional area A, the initial volume is \( V_0 = A L_0 \) and the final volume is \( V_1 = A L_1 \). The work done by the gas is:
\[ W_{gas} = nRT \ln\left(\frac{V_1}{V_0}\right) = nRT \ln\left(\frac{A L_1}{A L_0}\right) = nRT \ln\left(\frac{L_1}{L_0}\right) \]
Step 3: Calculate the work done by the gas using mechanics.
The work done by the gas is used to lift the piston and stretch the spring. This work is equal to the change in the mechanical potential energy of the system.
\[ W_{gas} = \Delta PE_{gravity} + \Delta PE_{spring} \]
The change in gravitational potential energy of the piston of mass M is:
\[ \Delta PE_{gravity} = Mg(L_1 - L_0) \]
The options provided suggest that the spring's restoring force depends on the absolute height L as \( F_{spring} = kL^3 \), rather than the extension from its natural length. While this is a non-standard assumption, it is necessary to match the given options. Under this assumption, the change in the spring's potential energy as the piston moves from \( L_0 \) to \( L_1 \) is:
\[ \Delta PE_{spring} = \int_{L_0}^{L_1} F_{spring} \,dL = \int_{L_0}^{L_1} kL^3 \,dL \] \[ \Delta PE_{spring} = \left[ \frac{kL^4}{4} \right]_{L_0}^{L_1} = \frac{k}{4}(L_1^4 - L_0^4) \]
Therefore, the total work done by the gas from the mechanical perspective is:
\[ W_{gas} = Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \frac{k}{4}(L_1^4 - L_0^4) \]
Final Computation & Result:
Step 4: Equate the two expressions for the work done by the gas.
We have two expressions for \( W_{gas} \), and they must be equal. This gives us the energy balance equation for the process.
\[ nRT \ln\left(\frac{L_1}{L_0}\right) = Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \frac{k}{4}(L_1^4 - L_0^4) \]
The question asks for the energy delivered by the filament, which is \( \Delta Q = W_{gas} \). The provided options are in the form of equations relating the thermodynamic work to the mechanical work. The derived equation exactly matches option (3).
Thus, the correct relationship describing the process is given by option (3). The energy delivered can be expressed by either side of this equation.
The correct option is (3).
Approach Solution -2
Using WET: Total energy supplied = gravitational potential energy + spring potential energy + work done by gas
\( Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \int_{0}^{L_1-L_0} kx dx + nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + W_{ext} = 0 \) \( \frac{k}{4} [x^4]_{0}^{L_1 - L_0} + Mg(L_1 - L_0) + \int_{0}^{L_1-L_0} kx dx + nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + W_{ext} = 0 \)
\( \frac{k}{4} (L_1^4 - L_0^4) + Mg(L_1 - L_0) + nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) + W_{ext} = 0 \) \( W_{ext} = \frac{k}{4} (L_1^4 - L_0^4) + Mg(L_1 - L_0) + nRT \ln \left( \frac{L_1}{L_0} \right) \)
Top Questions on Thermodynamics
- What is the freezing point depression constant of a solvent, 50 g of which contain 1 g non-volatile solute (molar mass 256 g mol\(^{-1}\)) and the decrease in freezing point is 0.40 K?
- JEE Main - 2025
- Chemistry
- Thermodynamics
For the reaction:
The correct order of set of reagents for the above conversion is :
- JEE Main - 2025
- Chemistry
- Thermodynamics
- A monoatomic gas is stored in a thermally insulated container. The gas is suddenly compressed to $ \frac{1}{8} $th of its initial volume. Find the ratio of final pressure to initial pressure.
- JEE Main - 2025
- Physics
- Thermodynamics
- A weak acid HA has degree of dissociation x. Which option gives the correct expression of \(pH - pK_a\)?
- JEE Main - 2025
- Chemistry
- Thermodynamics
- A liquid when kept inside a thermally insulated closed vessel at \(25^{\circ}C\) was mechanically stirred from outside. What will be the correct option for the following thermodynamic parameters?
- JEE Main - 2025
- Chemistry
- Thermodynamics
Questions Asked in JEE Main exam
Let $ P_n = \alpha^n + \beta^n $, $ n \in \mathbb{N} $. If $ P_{10} = 123,\ P_9 = 76,\ P_8 = 47 $ and $ P_1 = 1 $, then the quadratic equation having roots $ \alpha $ and $ \frac{1}{\beta} $ is:
- JEE Main - 2025
- Relations and functions
- The area of the region enclosed by the curves \( y = e^x \), \( y = |e^x - 1| \), and the y-axis is:
- JEE Main - 2025
- Functions
- The integral \[ 80 \int_0^{\frac{\pi}{4}} \frac{(\sin \theta + \cos \theta)}{(9 + 16 \sin 2\theta)} \, d\theta \] is equal to:
- JEE Main - 2025
- Functions
- The number of points of discontinuity of the function $ f(x) = \left\lfloor \frac{x^2}{2} \right\rfloor - \left\lfloor \sqrt{x} \right\rfloor, \quad x \in [0, 4], $ where $ \left\lfloor \cdot \right\rfloor $ denotes the greatest integer function, is:
- JEE Main - 2025
- Functions
An organic compound (X) with molecular formula $\mathrm{C}_{3} \mathrm{H}_{6} \mathrm{O}$ is not readily oxidised. On reduction it gives $\left(\mathrm{C}_{3} \mathrm{H}_{8} \mathrm{O}(\mathrm{Y})\right.$ which reacts with HBr to give a bromide (Z) which is converted to Grignard reagent. This Grignard reagent on reaction with (X) followed by hydrolysis give 2,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol. Compounds (X), (Y) and (Z) respectively are:
- JEE Main - 2025
- Organic Chemistry