Question

In which among the following, changes were introduced for environmental protection through the Constitution of India (42nd Amendment Act)?

• A. Fundamental Rights
• B. Fundamental Duties
• C. Directive Principles of State Policy
• D. 2, 3 only
• A. The signatory may take adequate measures to reduce carbon emission
• B. The signatory may take inadequate measures to reduce carbon emission
• C. The signatory should explore the possibility to reduce carbon emission
• D. The signatory may formulate necessary policies to reduce carbon emission
• A. Rivers & Lakes
• B. Forests & Wildlife
• C. All living creatures
• D. Only (A) and (B)
• A. The fundamental duty to preserve and protect natural resources is upon the State only
• B. Citizens have the fundamental duty to preserve and protect natural resources
• C. Both the state and citizens have the duty to preserve and protect natural resources
• D. Citizen’s duty to maintain ecological balance and citizens’ right against climate change
• A. Because of being a signatory of Indian national environmental conservation policies
• B. Because of the Supreme Court verdicts which explicitly make way for an enforceable right
• C. Because of the policy decisions of Government
• D. Because of the Constitution of India (42nd Amendment Act)
• A. Right to equality
• B. Right against exploitation
• C. Right to freedom of residence
• D. Right to life and personal liberty

Answer 1

The Correct Option is C

The 42nd Amendment Act of 1976 introduced key changes for environmental protection in the Indian Constitution. It added:

• Fundamental Duties: Article 51-A (g) was introduced, marking it a duty of every citizen to protect and improve the natural environment.
• Directive Principles of State Policy: Article 48-A was added to direct the State to protect and improve the environment as well as safeguard forests and wildlife.

Thus, the changes were made under both Fundamental Duties and Directive Principles of State Policy. In the context of the question, the correct option highlighting the change for environmental protection introduced through the 42nd Amendment Act is Directive Principles of State Policy.

Answer 2

To understand the nature of India's binding commitment to reduce carbon emissions through international treaties like the Paris Agreement, it's essential to comprehend India's obligations and legal context. The 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act of 1976 specifically incorporated environmental protection into the Constitution via Article 48-A and Article 51-A (g). The Indian Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that both state and citizens have a fundamental duty to protect natural resources.

During COP 21, India was among 196 countries to sign the Paris Agreement, committing to limit greenhouse gas emissions. Key objectives include generating 50% of energy from renewable sources, producing 500 GW from non-fossil fuels by 2030, and reducing carbon emissions by one billion tons. The Supreme Court's decision further enforces the right to a clean environment, aligning with Article 21 which guarantees the right to life, thus inferring a responsibility to maintain ecological balance.

Given this legal foundation and international commitment, the statement that best describes India's binding commitment is: The signatory may take adequate measures to reduce carbon emission. This reflects India's active and significant obligation to engage in measures that meaningfully address carbon emissions.

Answer 3

Under Article 51-A(g) of the Indian Constitution, it is explicitly mentioned that it is the duty of every citizen to protect and improve the natural environment. This includes diverse components of the environment that are crucial for maintaining ecological balance. According to the options provided, the following are included:

• Rivers & Lakes: These water bodies are significant for biodiversity, ecological balance, and serve as sources of water for various purposes ranging from domestic to industrial use.
• Forests & Wildlife: Forests are essential for carbon sequestration, oxygen production, and biodiversity conservation. Wildlife is equally important for maintaining natural ecosystems.

The duties outlined in Article 51-A(g) extend to protecting these features of the environment, among others, but it specifically calls out rivers, lakes, forests, and wildlife.

Given these explanations, the correct answer to what is explicitly mentioned in Article 51-A(g) is:

Only (A) and (B)

Answer 4

The question is centered on the fundamental duty regarding the preservation and protection of natural resources as interpreted by the Supreme Court in India. The comprehension provided gives an overview of how environmental protection is integrated into the Indian Constitution, mainly through Articles 48-A and 51-A (g), and acknowledges the Supreme Court's stance on this matter.

The comprehension specifies that the Court's judgments have ruled that both the state and its citizens share the responsibility to safeguard natural resources. This is further solidified by statements about the state's duty to maintain ecological balance and the citizens' right to a clean environment.

Analyzing the answer options given:

Option	Description
The fundamental duty to preserve and protect natural resources is upon the State only	Incorrect, as the duty is shared with citizens.
Citizens have the fundamental duty to preserve and protect natural resources	Incomplete, as the state also has this duty.
Both the state and citizens have the duty to preserve and protect natural resources	Correct, aligns with the Supreme Court's interpretation and constitutional provisions.
Citizen’s duty to maintain ecological balance and citizens’ right against climate change	Partially true but does not emphasize the state's responsibility.

Thus, the correct answer is: Both the state and citizens have the duty to preserve and protect natural resources, as this reflects the shared responsibility emphasized by the Supreme Court and the Indian Constitution.

Answer 5

The reason India is committed to reducing carbon emissions is primarily due to its status as a signatory of various international environmental conservation policies. As mentioned in the passage, India is part of numerous international treaties related to environmental conservation, which includes commitments to limit carbon emissions. Notably, India signed the Paris Agreement during COP 21 along with 196 countries. This agreement enforces universally binding commitments to keep global temperature rise well below 1.5 degrees Celsius compared to pre-industrial levels.

India's commitment involves increasing the share of renewable energy sources to 50% and generating 500 GW of energy from non-fossil fuels by 2030. Additionally, there is a goal of reducing carbon emissions by 1 billion tons and achieving net-zero carbon emissions by 2070. These commitments are indicative of India's adherence to international environmental policies rather than domestic constitutional amendments, Supreme Court verdicts, or purely national governmental policies.

Answer 6

The passage discusses the fundamental relationship between environmental protection and constitutional rights in India, specifically mentioning that any violation of essential environmental elements would equate to a violation of Article 21. The Supreme Court has supported this interpretation by recognizing the right to a clean environment as an extension of the right to life. Article 21 of the Indian Constitution states:

Article 21 - Protection of Life and Personal Liberty: "No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law."

This article ensures the right to life and personal liberty, a cornerstone of the Indian legal system. The association made in the passage refers to how environmental degradation may infringe upon these rights, emphasizing the state's duty to maintain ecological balance. Therefore, the correct answer to the question posed is "Right to life and personal liberty".