We are given that:
\[
A^T = \alpha A + I \quad \text{and} \quad \text{det}(A^2 - A) = 4
\]
We start by simplifying the expression for \( A^2 - A \). First, express \( A^T \) as:
\[
A^T = \alpha A + I
\]
Thus, we have:
\[
A = \alpha(A + I) + I
\]
\[
A = \alpha A + (\alpha + 1)I
\]
Now, calculate the determinant \( |A - I| \). From the above, we know that:
\[
|A - I| = \frac{1}{(1 - \alpha^2)} \quad \text{(Equation 3)}
\]
Next, from the equation \( \text{det}(A^2 - A) \), we have:
\[
A^2 - A = \left|A - I\right|
\]
Substituting the value, we find that the determinant of \( A^2 - A \) is 4:
\[
\text{det}(A^2 - A) = 4
\]
After solving the quadratic equation, we find that the sum of possible values of \( \alpha \) is \( \frac{5}{2} \).