Comprehension
Everything she wanted was here, at Carignano, in Kasauli. Here, on the ridge of the mountain, in this quiet house. It was the place, and the time of life, that she had wanted and prepared for all her life-as she realized on the first day at Carignano, with a great, cool flowering of relief - and at last she had it. She wanted no one and nothing else. Whatever else came, or happened here, would be an unwelcome intrusion and distraction. This she tried to convey to the plodding postman with a cold and piercing stare from the height of the ridge onto his honest bull back. Unfortunately, he did not look up at her on the hilltop but stared stolidly down at the dust piling onto his shoes as he plodded on. A bullock-man, an oafish ox, she thought bitterly. She stepped backwards into the garden and the wind suddenly billowed up and threw the pine branches about as though to curtain her. She was grey, tall and thin and her silk sari made a sweeping, shivering sound and she fancied she could merge with the pine trees and be mistaken for one. To be a tree, no more and no less, was all she was prepared to undertake.
What pleased and satisfied her so, here at Carignano, was its barrenness. This was the chief virtue of all Kasauli of course-its starkness. It had rocks, it had pines, it had light and air. In every direction there was a sweeping view - to the north, of the mountains, to the south, of the plains. Occasionally an eagle swam through this clear unobstructed mass of light and air, that was all. And Carignano, her home on the ridge, had no more than that. Why should it? The sun shone on its white walls. Its windows were open the ones facing north opened on to the blue waves of the Himalayas flowing out and up to the line of ice and snow sketched upon the sky, while those that faced south looked down the plunging cliff to the plain stretching out, flat and sere to the blurred horizon. 
Yes, there were some apricot trees close to the house. There were clumps of iris that had finished blooming. There was the kitchen with a wing of smoke lifting out of its chimney and a stack of wood outside its door. But these were incidental, almost unimportant. 
[Extracted, with edits and revisions, from “Fire on the Mountain” by Anita Desai]
Question: 1

What does the protagonist’s preference for “barrenness” and “starkness” at Carignano suggest about her personality?

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • She enjoys a bustling and vibrant environment
  • She values simplicity and minimalism in her surroundings.
  • She prefers lush and colorful landscapes.
  • She seeks constant stimulation and variety in her life.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the protagonist’s feelings about Carignano:
The passage describes the protagonist's profound sense of relief and satisfaction upon arriving at Carignano in Kasauli. She is content with the barrenness of the place, seeing it as a place she had longed for, prepared for, and finally found. This satisfaction is centered around the simplicity of the environment, which is depicted as sparse yet beautiful, with only the essential elements of nature present—rocks, pines, light, and air.

Step 2: Analyzing the protagonist’s relationship with her surroundings:
The protagonist emphasizes the starkness of Kasauli, particularly Carignano, and finds peace in its simplicity. She enjoys the sweeping views of the mountains and plains, and even finds beauty in the simplicity of the house with its white walls, open windows, and natural surroundings. The protagonist does not desire any further additions to her environment; she sees the barrenness as the key virtue of her home. Her desire to merge with the pine trees reflects her wish to be part of this uncomplicated, natural setting.

Step 3: Connecting this preference to the correct answer:
The passage strongly suggests that the protagonist prefers a simple, unadorned environment where nature is allowed to remain in its purest form. This focus on the essential, unspoiled elements of nature aligns with a desire for simplicity and minimalism in her surroundings.

Step 4: Conclusion:
The correct answer is option (B): She values simplicity and minimalism in her surroundings, as the protagonist’s satisfaction with Carignano is rooted in her appreciation for its simplicity and natural beauty.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2

What do you get to know about the protagonist’s state of mind from her reaction towards the postman?

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • She feels grateful for his presence and the assistance he offers
  • She dislikes any disturbance or interruption in her solitude.
  • She feels suspicious and is interested in the lives of others.
  • She is disinterested and generally unaffected by the presence of others.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the protagonist's emotional state:
The passage presents the protagonist’s reaction to the postman, who arrives at Carignano. Her cold and piercing stare, described as an attempt to communicate her desire for solitude, reveals that she is not welcoming any interruptions. Her physical actions and expression convey frustration with the intrusion of her personal space.

Step 2: Analyzing her desire for solitude:
The protagonist finds peace in the barrenness and simplicity of her surroundings, and she clearly values her solitude. The passage details how she steps back into the garden and becomes more immersed in her isolation, symbolized by the wind blowing through the pine trees and her wish to merge with them. This indicates a deep longing to be left alone, without disturbance or interference from others.

Step 3: Evaluating the protagonist's reaction to the postman:
The protagonist’s cold and piercing stare at the postman—who is unaware of her feelings and focused on his task—shows that she is irritated by his presence. This reaction reinforces the idea that she is not interested in engaging with anyone who disturbs her peace and solitude. Her feelings of annoyance towards the postman further highlight her desire to remain undisturbed.

Step 4: Conclusion:
The correct answer is option (B): She dislikes any disturbance or interruption in her solitude, as the protagonist’s reaction to the postman shows her irritation with any form of interruption to her solitude, which is a central theme in the passage.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3

What does the protagonist’s desire to be mistaken for a pine tree reveal about her mindset?

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • She desires to be appreciated and noticed by others in society
  • She has a deep admiration for the beauty of the pine trees.
  • She feels a sense of superiority over other living beings.
  • She yearns to one with nature and escapes from her human identity
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the protagonist’s feelings about nature:
The passage describes the protagonist as standing in her garden, observing the pine trees around her, and wishing that she could merge with them. This imagery reflects her deep connection with nature and her desire to become part of the natural world, rather than simply being a detached human observer.

Step 2: Analyzing the symbolic meaning of merging with the pine trees:
The protagonist imagines herself blending with the pine trees, imagining that she could be mistaken for one of them. This desire to "merge" with the trees is a powerful metaphor for her wish to escape from the confines of human identity and experience the peace and simplicity of nature. The action suggests that she is seeking a deeper sense of unity with the natural world, where she can shed her human traits and become part of the serene environment around her.

Step 3: Understanding the protagonist's longing for peace and unity:
The protagonist's desire to merge with nature reflects her yearning for peace, tranquility, and a sense of belonging to something larger than herself. She is not simply enjoying the view of the trees, but rather, she longs to become one with them—highlighting her need to escape from the complexity of human life and identity.

Step 4: Conclusion:
The correct answer is option (D): She yearns to be one with nature and escape from her human identity, as her wish to merge with the pine trees symbolizes a desire to escape the human condition and find peace and unity within the natural world.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4

The protagonist’s description of the nestlings’ screams as “shrill and maddening” shows that:

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • She perceives the sounds to be out of tune yet soothing.
  • She considers the nestlings to be symbols of new life and vitality
  • She finds the nestlings to be vexatious and irritating
  • She feels a sense of protectiveness and care towards the nestlings
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is C

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the protagonist’s reaction to the nestlings:
In the passage, the protagonist is described as finding the sounds of the nestlings to be "shrill and maddening." This choice of words reflects her negative emotional reaction to the birds, indicating that their noise is causing her irritation. The use of harsh and unsettling descriptors, such as "shrill" and "maddening," emphasizes her annoyance with the nestlings.

Step 2: Analyzing the protagonist's inability to appreciate vitality:
The protagonist’s reaction to the nestlings highlights her inability or unwillingness to appreciate their youthful energy and vitality. Instead of seeing the nestlings as part of the natural beauty of her environment, she perceives them as a nuisance. This suggests that she is more focused on her desire for solitude and peace, rather than engaging with the vibrancy of life around her.

Step 3: Connecting her reaction to the correct answer:
The protagonist’s response to the nestlings is clear from the words used to describe them: "shrill" and "maddening." These words indicate her vexation, rather than any appreciation for the natural world. Her irritation reflects that she finds the nestlings to be a disturbance.

Step 4: Conclusion:
The correct answer is option (C): She finds the nestlings to be vexatious and irritating, as the protagonist's reaction to the sounds of the nestlings reveals her irritation and inability to appreciate their vitality.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 5

Which of the following statements are true about the protagonist’s overall state of mind in Carignano?
Statement I: She experienced a sense of constant restlessness and anguish.
Statement II: She felt isolated and disconnected from her environment.
Statement III: She was content, fulfilled, and at peace with her surroundings.

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • Statement I and II
  • Statement II and III
  • Only Statement II
  • Only Statement III
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Analyzing the protagonist’s emotional state:
The passage describes the protagonist’s feelings after arriving at Carignano in Kasauli. Initially, she is relieved and satisfied with her new surroundings, finding peace in the barrenness and simplicity of the place. She does not experience restlessness or anguish, but instead, she feels fulfilled and content with her solitude and the natural environment around her.

Step 2: Evaluating the truth of the statements:
- Statement I: "She experienced a sense of constant restlessness and anguish."
This statement does not align with the passage. The protagonist feels relief and contentment, not restlessness or anguish. She values the stillness and simplicity of Carignano, and there is no indication that she experiences emotional turmoil.

- Statement II: "She felt isolated and disconnected from her environment."
This statement is also false. While the protagonist enjoys solitude, it is not because she feels disconnected. She actively seeks to merge with nature and is content in her environment, reflecting a sense of unity with her surroundings.

- Statement III: "She was content, fulfilled, and at peace with her surroundings."
This statement is true. The passage clearly describes how the protagonist finds peace, relief, and contentment in Carignano. She enjoys the simplicity and natural beauty of the place, and her emotional state is one of fulfillment and tranquility.

Step 3: Conclusion:
The correct answer is Only Statement III, as it accurately reflects the protagonist’s state of mind, which is one of contentment and peace with her surroundings.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 6

In the light of above passage, what role does nature play in the protagonist’s life at Carignano?

Updated On: Jun 11, 2025
  • It provides her with a source of creativity
  • It offers her solace, peace, and a sense of belonging.
  • It serves as a reminder of the harsh realities of life
  • It serves as a constant source of distraction and intrusion for her.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the protagonist's emotional state:
The passage clearly explains that the protagonist finds peace and satisfaction in Carignano due to its simplicity and natural barrenness. She feels a deep sense of relief and fulfillment upon arriving at the place, which she had longed for and prepared for all her life. This emotional satisfaction reflects her connection with the surroundings, which offer solace and peace.

Step 2: Analyzing the protagonist’s connection to her surroundings:
The protagonist describes the environment in Carignano as being sparse yet beautiful, with elements like rocks, pines, light, and air. She is not disturbed by the absence of excess; instead, she finds tranquility in the simplicity and quietness of the place. This connection to her surroundings gives her a sense of belonging, as she feels at home and at peace in this isolated environment.

Step 3: Evaluating the provided options:
- Option (B) directly refers to the protagonist finding solace, peace, and a sense of belonging in her surroundings, which aligns perfectly with the emotions she expresses in the passage.

- Other options may not fully capture the protagonist's feelings, as they might focus on aspects like frustration or discomfort, which are not evident in the passage.

Step 4: Conclusion:
The correct answer is option (B): It offers her solace, peace, and a sense of belonging, as this accurately reflects the protagonist’s deep satisfaction and emotional connection with the natural environment of Carignano.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top Questions on Reading Comprehension

View More Questions

Questions Asked in CLAT exam

View More Questions