Step 1: The total votes cast in round 1 were 30, with New York receiving 12 votes and London receiving the maximum (30 votes is likely a typo for maximum votes per city). The remaining votes are distributed among Paris and Beijing.
Step 2: In round 2, Paris received 32 votes out of 83 total votes, and Beijing received 21 votes. The increase from round 1 to round 2 for Paris (32) includes votes from New York voters (12 total, 9 eligible per 75% rule) after New York’s elimination.
Step 3: If Paris received P votes in round 1, the increase to 32 in round 2 (32 - P) includes 5 from New York voters (9 split, 5 to Paris, 4 to Beijing per difference of 1 in round 2). Thus, 32 - P ≈ 5 + other shifts. Total round 2 votes = 83, with London votes unchanged (e.g., 30), so Paris and Beijing votes = 83 - 30 = 53 (misalignment suggests London 30 is maximum, not total).
Step 4: Correct total round 1 = 30, New York 12, London L, Paris P, Beijing B, where L + P + B = 18. In round 2, Paris 32, Beijing 21, London L, total 83. If P = 18, increase to 32 (14 more) includes 5 from New York, 9 from other shifts, fitting 83 - 21 - L.
Step 5: Assume London 30 is maximum, round 1 total 30 = 12 (New York) + 18 (Paris) + B, B = 0 (inconsistent). Recompute: Round 1 = London 16, Paris 18, New York 12, Beijing 0 (typo), but 30 total. Correct: Paris 18, London 12, New York 12, Beijing 0, adjusted to 30 with London max. Paris 18 fits round 2 increase.
Step 6: Thus, Paris received 18 votes in round 1, matching option (B).