Step 1: Briefly describe the structure of chlorophyll. It has a porphyrin ring with a magnesium ion at its center and a long hydrocarbon tail called a phytol group. This tail makes chlorophyll fat-soluble.
Step 2: Describe the effect of alkali treatment. When chlorophyll is treated with a strong alkali (like NaOH or KOH), a process called saponification occurs. The ester linkage holding the phytol tail is cleaved, removing the tail.
Step 3: Identify the resulting product. The product is a salt called chlorophyllin. It still contains the magnesium ion and the porphyrin ring, so it retains a bright green color, but without the phytol tail, it becomes water-soluble.
In contrast, acid treatment removes the central magnesium ion, replacing it with hydrogen, to form the dull olive-brown compound pheophytin.