Question

Why does the author say that copying American films is wrong?

Hint:

When analyzing a critical essay like Ray's, focus on the author's core argument. Ray's main point is the need for "Indianness" and originality in cinema. Any question about his views will likely relate to this central theme.

Answer 1

Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This question refers to Satyajit Ray's essay, 'What is Wrong with Indian Films?'. The central theme is a critique of the lack of originality and quality in mainstream Indian cinema of his time.

Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
Ray provides two main reasons why copying is wrong:
1. Lack of Cultural Authenticity: Ray believed that cinema is a form of artistic expression that should reflect the realities of its own environment. American life, customs, and social norms are vastly different from Indian ones. Copying Hollywood plots and conventions onto an Indian setting creates a product that feels false and fails to connect with the audience on a genuine level.
2. Stifles Creativity: Relying on foreign formulas is a sign of a "poverty of imagination." Instead of developing unique stories and cinematic techniques that are true to India's own rich traditions, filmmakers take the easy route of imitation. This prevents the growth and maturation of a truly Indian cinematic language.