Comprehension

Time and again, whenever a population of [Mexican tetra fish] was swept into a cave and survived long enough for natural selection to have its way, the caves adapted. ”But it’s not that they have been losing their vision,” as one of the authors of the study explains. ”Studies have found that cave-dwelling fish can detect lower levels of amino acids than surface fish can. They have also more tastebuds and a higher density of sensitive cells alongside their bodies that let them sense water pressure and flow . . .” 
Killing the processes that support the formation of the eye is quite literally what happens. Just like non-cave-dwelling members of the species, all cavefish embryos start making eyes. But after a few hours, cells in the developing eye get tiny until the entire structure has disappeared. (Developmental biologist Melody Riddle thinks this apparent inefficiency may be unavoidable: ”The development of the brain and the eye are completely intertwined—so when eyes disappear, it impacts the entire biology of the animal. It’s hard to tell exactly how they happen together,” she says. That means the last step in survival for eye-less animals may be to start making an eye and then get rid of it. . . .
It’s easy to see why cavefish would be at a disadvantage if they were to maintain excessive tissues they aren’t using. Since relatively little lives or grows in their caves, the fish are likely surviving on a meager diet of mostly bat feces and organic waste that washes in during the rainy season. Researchers keeping cavefish in labs have discovered that cavefish are exquisitely adapted to absorbing and using nutrients. . . .
Cells can be toxic for tissues, [evolutionary physiologist Nicolas] Rohner explains, so they are stored in fat cells. ”But when these cells get too big, they can burst, which is why we often see chronic inflammation in humans and other animals that have stored a lot of fat in their tissues.” Yet a 2020 study by Riddle, Rohner and their colleagues revealed that even very well-fed cavefish had fewer signs of inflammation in their fat tissues than surface fish do. Even in their sparse cave conditions, wild cavefish can sometimes get very fat, says Riddle. This is presumably because, whenever food piles up in the cave, the fish eat as much of it as possible, since there might not be enough for a long time to come. Intriguingly, Riddle says, their fat is usually bright yellow, because of high levels of carotenoids, the substance in the carrots that your grandmother used to tell you were good for your...eyes. ”The first thing that came to our mind, of course, was that they were accumulating these compounds because they don’t have eyes,” says Riddle. In this species, such ideas can be tested: Scientists can cross surface fish (with eyes) and cavefish (without eyes) and look at what their offspring are like. When that’s done, Riddle says, researchers see no link between eye presence or size and the accumulation of carotenoids. Some eyeless cavefish had fat that was completely white, indicating lower carotenoid levels. Instead, Riddle thinks these carotenoids may be another adaptation to suppress inflammation, which might be important in the wild, as cavefish are likely eating whenever food arrives.

Question: 1

All of the following statements from the passage describe adaptation in Mexican tetra cavefish EXCEPT:

Show Hint

Adaptations often help organisms survive in their specific environments, like cavefish evolving to thrive on minimal resources while maintaining health through unique biological processes.
Updated On: Dec 4, 2025
  • Since relatively little lives or grows in their caves, the fish are likely surviving on a meager diet of mostly bat feces and organic waste that washes in during the rainy season.
  • Even in their sparse cave conditions, wild cavefish can sometimes get very fat, says Riddle.
  • It’s easy to see why cavefish would be at a disadvantage if they were to maintain excessive tissues they aren’t using.
  • But when these cells get too big, they can burst, which is why we often see chronic inflammation in humans and other animals that have stored a lot of fat in their tissues.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the Passage:
The passage discusses the adaptation of Mexican tetra cavefish to their environment. It highlights how their tissues, particularly fat cells, adapt to limited food resources in the cave system.
Step 2: Analyzing the Options:
- (1) This statement is consistent with the passage’s description of the fish surviving on meager resources in their cave habitat.
- (2) This option also aligns with the passage, as it discusses cavefish getting fat even in sparse conditions.
- (3) This statement describes a logical adaptation of cavefish, which avoids retaining tissues not useful in their environment.
- (4) This statement, while describing a common biological phenomenon, does not directly relate to the adaptation of Mexican tetra cavefish in the passage.
Step 3: Conclusion:
Option (4) is the exception because it relates to a general biological fact rather than a specific adaptation of Mexican tetra cavefish.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2

On the basis of the information in the passage, what is the most likely function of carotenoids in Mexican tetra cavefish?

Show Hint

Carotenoids in animals can serve various functions, such as controlling inflammation and giving color to tissues, as seen in Mexican tetra cavefish.
Updated On: Dec 4, 2025
  • To act as a substitute for eyes.
  • To control inflammation from the bursting of fat cells.
  • To render bright yellow colour to the cavefish.
  • To help the fat cells store nutrients.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the Passage:
The passage suggests that carotenoids play a role in preventing inflammation in the fat cells of the Mexican tetra cavefish. This is important as the fat cells can burst, leading to inflammation.
Step 2: Analyzing the Options:
- (1) This option is not supported by the passage, as carotenoids are not described as a substitute for eyes.
- (2) This option aligns with the passage, which explains how carotenoids help control inflammation from the bursting of fat cells.
- (3) While carotenoids are responsible for the yellow color, this is not the primary function described in the passage.
- (4) This option is not supported by the passage, as carotenoids are not described as helping fat cells store nutrients.
Step 3: Conclusion:
Option (2) best explains the likely function of carotenoids in Mexican tetra cavefish, based on the passage.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3

Which one of the following results for the cross between surface fish (with eyes) and cavefish (without eyes) would invalidate Riddle’s inference from the experiment?

Show Hint

In genetic experiments, the presence or absence of certain traits in offspring can provide evidence for or against a hypothesis about those traits.
Updated On: Dec 4, 2025
  • Some offspring with eyes had white fat.
  • Only eyeless offspring had yellow fat.
  • Some offspring with eyes had yellow fat.
  • Some eyeless offspring had white fat.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding Riddle’s Inference:
Riddle’s inference suggests that the accumulation of yellow fat in cavefish is related to the absence of eyes. The cross between surface and cavefish is meant to test this hypothesis.
Step 2: Analyzing the Options:
- (1) This result would not invalidate the inference, as it still shows the expected outcome of yellow fat in eyeless fish.
- (2) This result would invalidate the inference, as it shows yellow fat in only eyeless offspring, which does not support the idea that yellow fat is linked to the absence of eyes.
- (3) This result supports the inference by showing that some offspring with eyes have yellow fat, as expected.
- (4) This result is consistent with the hypothesis, showing yellow fat in eyeless offspring.
Step 3: Conclusion:
Option (2) would invalidate Riddle’s inference because it shows that only eyeless offspring had yellow fat.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4

Which one of the following best explains why the “apparent inefficiency” is “unavoidable”?

Show Hint

In adaptation, some inefficiencies may be unavoidable due to biological constraints and the need for compensatory adaptations.
Updated On: Dec 4, 2025
  • The lack of light in the caves kills the eye cells in the developing Mexican tetra cavefish embryo.
  • The inefficiency resulting from eyelessness is compensated by enhancements like more tastebuds in Mexican tetra cavefish.
  • The caves have poor and inconsistent availability of food and nutrition for Mexican tetra cavefish.
  • Mexican tetra cavefish are similar to non-cave-dwelling variants in their early stages of development.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Understanding the Passage:
The passage discusses how the inefficiency of Mexican tetra cavefish development is due to the loss of eye cells and their initial similarity to non-cave-dwelling fish.
Step 2: Analyzing the Options:
- (1) This option focuses on the lack of light, but the inefficiency is more about the adaptation process of cavefish.
- (2) This option is supported by the passage, as it explains how compensations like more tastebuds make up for the inefficiency.
- (3) This option is not directly mentioned as a cause of inefficiency in the passage.
- (4) This option aligns with the passage, explaining how the inefficiency is an unavoidable part of cavefish development.
Step 3: Conclusion:
Option (4) is the best explanation for why the inefficiency is unavoidable.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top Questions on Reading Comprehension

View More Questions

Questions Asked in CAT exam

View More Questions