There is a statement followed by two arguments. Choose the correct option which gives the decision on the arguments, which is derived from the statement.
LPG subsidy is a stand taken by the government. Linking of Aadhar card to a bank account has been made mandatory for receiving the subsidy.
Argument I: All people should give up LPG subsidies.
Argument II: To fill the gap between poor and rich.
LPG subsidy is a stand taken by the government. Linking of Aadhar card to a bank account has been made mandatory for receiving the subsidy.
Argument I: All people should give up LPG subsidies.
Argument II: To fill the gap between poor and rich.
- Argument II is the output of Argument I
- Argument I is a byproduct of Argument II
- Argument I and Argument II are complementing to each other
- No logical link between Argument I and Argument II
The Correct Option is D
Solution and Explanation
The given statement discusses the linkage of the Aadhar card to bank accounts for receiving LPG subsidies. Argument I suggests that all people should relinquish these subsidies, while Argument II suggests doing so would bridge the gap between the affluent and the less fortunate.
To evaluate the relationship between Argument I and Argument II, let's analyze the content and intent behind both. Argument I implies a voluntary act of giving up subsidies by everyone, including those in different economic strata, to possibly reduce the burden on the government's resources. In contrast, Argument II addresses socioeconomic disparity, suggesting that such a measure could improve equality between rich and poor.
However, there is no direct causation or logical dependency between the two arguments. Simply giving up subsidies is not a specific solution for addressing societal inequalities; likewise, the motive to bridge the rich-poor gap does not inherently result in everyone giving up subsidies. The two arguments present separate issues and intentions without a clear, logical correlation.
Thus, the correct conclusion is:
No logical link between Argument I and Argument II
Top Questions on Syllogisms
- If all roses are flowers and some flowers are red, which statement must be true?
- Statements:
(I) All Forces are energies
(II) All energies are powers
(III) No power is heat
Conclusions:
(I) Some forces are definitely not powers
(II) No heat is force - In the question below are given three statements followed by three conclusions numbered I, II, and III. You have to take the given statements to be true, even if they seem to be at variance from the commonly known facts. Read all the conclusions and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follow/s from the given statements disregarding commonly known facts. Statements:
- Some mountains are hillocks.
- Some mountains are rivers.
- Some mountains are valleys.
Conclusions:
I. All mountains are either hillocks or rivers or valleys.
II. No valley is river.
III. Some rivers are valleys. - Three statements are followed by four conclusions I, II, III, and IV. Take the given statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance with commonly known facts and decide which of the given conclusions logically follow from the given statements. Statements:
1. All animals are vegetables.
2. All fishes are vegetables.
3. All birds are fishes.
Conclusions:
I. Some birds are animals.
II. Some vegetables are fishes.
III. Some vegetables are animals.
IV. All birds are vegetables. - If no scholars are athletes, and some athletes are musicians, can we infer that no scholars are musicians?
Questions Asked in SNAP exam
Consider the following alphanumeric series with powers:
A1, C3, E5, G7, __, __, I9, __,K11, M13, __
Based on the observed pattern, complete the series by selecting the correct options:
- SNAP - 2023
- Sequence and Series
Consider the following information:
Set A: Animals that can fly
Set B: Birds
Set C: Animals that live in water
Using Venn diagrams, represent the relationships between these sets and answer the question. Which region(s) in the Venn diagram represents animals that can fly and also live in water?
- SNAP - 2023
- Venn Diagrams
Arrange the following words in lexicographical (dictionary) order from highest to lowest:
1. Elephant
2. Banana
3. Apple
4. Cherry
- SNAP - 2023
- Venn Diagrams
A trader marked up shirts by 40%, offered a 20% discount during a sale, and sold each for 234. Find the number of shirts he purchased.
- SNAP - 2023
- Profit and Loss
In a collection of coins, the ratio of the number of 2-rupee coins to 5-rupee coins to 1-rupee coins is \(3 : 4 : 5\). If the total value of these coins is Rs. 18.75, how much money is represented by the 5-rupee coins?
- SNAP - 2023
- Ratio and Proportion