Let us consider the cases of Shweta and Rani. While Shweta has access to, and can afford to buy good quality dairy products, she and her spouse decide to pursue a vegan lifestyle. Therefore, she no longer buys milk or dairy-based products for her family. Rani’s family on the other hand, has a meagre income. Although Rani’s children like milk and kheer, Rani refrains from buying milk and instead spends on rice.
In light of the concepts of functioning and capability as defined by Martha Nussbaum, which one of the following options holds for the above cases?
In light of the concepts of functioning and capability as defined by Martha Nussbaum, which one of the following options holds for the above cases?
Show Hint
- They differ on the basis of capability
- They differ on the basis of functioning
- They differ on the basis of both functioning and capability
- They do not differ since the end-result is the same in both
The Correct Option is A
Solution and Explanation
In Martha Nussbaum’s framework, "functioning" refers to what a person can actually do (their achievements), whereas "capability" refers to the real opportunities they have to achieve things. Shweta and Rani differ in their capabilities, as Shweta has the financial freedom to choose a vegan lifestyle, while Rani is constrained by her financial situation. Therefore, their differing capabilities affect their choices.
Step 2: Analyzing the options.
- (A) They differ on the basis of capability: This is correct, as the difference in their financial situations reflects a difference in their capabilities to make choices.
- (B) They differ on the basis of functioning: This is incorrect, as both women’s functioning might involve similar dietary choices, but their capabilities are different.
- (C) They differ on the basis of both functioning and capability: This is incorrect because the primary difference is in their capabilities, not their actual functioning.
- (D) They do not differ since the end-result is the same in both: This is incorrect, as the end-result is achieved through different capabilities, not identical circumstances.
Step 3: Conclusion.
The correct answer is (A) because their difference lies in their capabilities rather than their actual functioning.
Top Questions on Philosophy
- Who among the following political thinkers considered law as 'nothing else than the command of the sovereign in the exercise of his sovereign power'?
- Which among the following is NOT the major law of dialectical materialism?
- Who among the following political thinkers considered the state of nature as "war of every man against every man"?
- Who among the following political thinkers believed that Satya is the essence of Dharma?
- Which among the following is not the principal aim of the UN as elaborated in its founding Charter?
Questions Asked in GATE XH- C4 exam
Eight students (P, Q, R, S, T, U, V, and W) are playing musical chairs. The figure indicates their order of position at the start of the game. They play the game by moving forward in a circle in the clockwise direction.
After the 1st round, the 4th student behind P leaves the game.
After the 2nd round, the 5th student behind Q leaves the game.
After the 3rd round, the 3rd student behind V leaves the game.
After the 4th round, the 4th student behind U leaves the game.
Who all are left in the game after the 4th round?
The 12 musical notes are given as \( C, C^\#, D, D^\#, E, F, F^\#, G, G^\#, A, A^\#, B \). Frequency of each note is \( \sqrt[12]{2} \) times the frequency of the previous note. If the frequency of the note C is 130.8 Hz, then the ratio of frequencies of notes F# and C is:
Here are two analogous groups, Group-I and Group-II, that list words in their decreasing order of intensity. Identify the missing word in Group-II.
Abuse \( \rightarrow \) Insult \( \rightarrow \) Ridicule
__________ \( \rightarrow \) Praise \( \rightarrow \) Appreciate
- Had I learnt acting as a child, I ________ a famous film star.
Select the most appropriate option to complete the above sentence. - A car started from city P at 9:40 AM. The time taken for the car to reach city Q is 4 hours and 50 minutes. The time of arrival of the car at city Q is: