Question:
How do the characters of Rajkumar Shukla from 'Indigo' and William Douglas from 'Deep Water' compare and contrast in terms of their courage, constraints, and determination? (Indigo and Deep Water)
How do the characters of Rajkumar Shukla from 'Indigo' and William Douglas from 'Deep Water' compare and contrast in terms of their courage, constraints, and determination? (Indigo and Deep Water)
Show Hint
In comparison-based answers, highlight one similarity and one contrast, linking both to the central theme.
Updated On: Jul 3, 2025
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
Solution and Explanation
Rajkumar Shukla and William Douglas, though from different contexts, represent true grit and resilience. Shukla, an illiterate but determined farmer, overcomes the barrier of social class and persistently convinces Gandhi to visit Champaran. Despite lacking education or influence, his commitment to justice for indigo farmers showcases silent strength, moral courage, and unwavering faith in truth and leadership. William Douglas, on the other hand, faces a deeply personal psychological fear—a traumatic near-drowning experience in childhood. His struggle is internal, marked by anxiety and dread. Yet, through consistent training, discipline, and mental fortitude, he conquers his fear and reclaims control over his life. His journey becomes symbolic of confronting and defeating one's inner demons. While Shukla battles societal oppression and Douglas overcomes internal trauma, both demonstrate that real courage is persistence in the face of fear. Their determination proves that resilience—whether social or personal—can empower individuals to rise above constraints and inspire others. Both men ultimately emerge as figures of transformation, showing that courage is not limited to grand gestures—it often lies in quiet, relentless perseverance. Their lives teach us that change begins with one strong decision to not give up, no matter the odds.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top Questions on Indigo
- Why did Gandhi agree to a settlement of 25% refund to the farmers? (Indigo)
- Give a brief account of the reception that Gandhi got in Motihari.
- Compare how Gandhi’s courage and his determination in ‘Indigo’ helped him get justice for sharecroppers with William Douglas’ courage and persistence in the chapter ‘Deep Water’. (Indigo and Deep Water)
“This settlement was adopted unanimously by the commission. Gandhi explained that the amount of the refund was less important than the fact that the landlords had been obliged to surrender part of the money and, with it, part of their prestige. Therefore, as far as the peasants were concerned, the planters had behaved as lords above the law. Now the peasant saw that he had rights and defenders. He learned courage.”
- Read the following extracts and answer the questions
Their spontaneous demonstration, in thousands, around the courthouse was the beginning of their liberation from fear of the British. The officials felt powerless without Gandhi’s cooperation. He helped them regulate the crowd. He was polite and friendly. He was giving them concrete proof that their might, hitherto dreaded and unquestioned, could be challenged by Indians. The government was baffled. The prosecutor requested the judge to postpone the trial. Apparently, the authorities wished to consult their superiors.
View More Questions
Questions Asked in CBSE CLASS XII exam
- In the circuit, three ideal cells of e.m.f. \( V \), \( V \), and \( 2V \) are connected to a resistor of resistance \( R \), a capacitor of capacitance \( C \), and another resistor of resistance \( 2R \) as shown in the figure. In the steady state, find (i) the potential difference between P and Q, (ii) the potential difference across capacitor C.
- CBSE CLASS XII - 2025
- Current electricity
- Calculate the molality of a solution prepared by dissolving 5 g of NaOH in 450 g of water. (Molar mass of NaOH = 40 g/mol)
- An aqueous solution of NaOH was made and its molar mass from the measurement of osmotic pressure at 27°C was found to be 25 g mol$^{-1$.}
Calculate the percentage dissociation of NaOH in this solution.- CBSE CLASS XII - 2025
- Solutions
- A small conducting sphere A of radius \( r \) charged to a potential \( V \), is enclosed by a spherical conducting shell B of radius \( R \). If A and B are connected by a thin wire, calculate the final potential on sphere A and shell B.
- CBSE CLASS XII - 2025
- Electric charges and fields
- You are Mrs. Savita Manjrekhar, a professor in English. You are invited to be one of the judges for the inter-school debate competition by the Principal of J.M. Public School, Cochin. Write a formal letter expressing your inability to accept the invitation.
- CBSE CLASS XII - 2025
- Letter Writing
View More Questions