- Step 1: List constraints. A not History. B not Math. C not English. Each chooses a different subject.
- Step 2: Assign subjects. Subjects: History, Math, Science, English. B not Math, so B has History, Science, or English. C not English, so C has History, Math, or Science. A not History, so A has Math, Science, or English.
- Step 3: Test Science. Assume A has Science. Then: B has History or English, C has History or Math, D gets the remaining subject.
- Step 4: Assign remaining. If B has History, C has Math (not English), D has English. Check: A-Science, B-History, C-Math, D-English. Constraints: A not History (satisfied), B not Math (satisfied), C not English (satisfied).
- Step 5: Verify other possibilities. If B has English, C has Math, D has History, A has Science. Valid. Science consistently goes to A.
- Step 6: Final conclusion. Option (1) A is the correct answer.