Comprehension
A University coach was asked to select teams in three sports: Shooting, Cricket (batsmen only) and “Snakes & Ladder”. The honest and keen observer head boy of the school informed the coach that he had observed 100 students playing the three games - shooting, cricket and “Snakes & Ladder”. In shooting, all students were given 100 chances to hit a target. In cricket, a batsman faced a maximum of 100 balls, provided he DID NOT GET OUT.
In “Snakes & Ladder”, every student could play 100 matches, one each with the other students and one against a computer. In shooting, a player got one point for hitting the target and zero point for missing the target. In cricket, a batsman got one point for hitting the ball and zero point for missing it. In “Snakes & Ladder”, a person got one point for winning the game and zero for losing. To the coach’s utter surprise, the distribution of points across all three games was the same. It was as follows:
| Points Scored | Number of Students |
|---|---|
| 0 - 9 | 1 |
| 10 - 19 | 8 |
| 20 - 29 | 5 |
| 30 - 39 | 15 |
| 40 - 49 | 20 |
| 50 - 59 | 20 |
| 60 - 69 | 13 |
| 70 - 79 | 7 |
| 80 - 89 | 9 |
| 90 - 99 | 2 |
Question: 1
Which of the following options is the best way to select the “Snakes & Ladder” team?
Which of the following options is the best way to select the “Snakes & Ladder” team?
Show Hint
When conditions seem restrictive or arbitrary, the most logical answer is often the option that provides maximum flexibility to achieve the main objective.
Updated On: Aug 23, 2025
- The coach must select all students between 80 and 99.
- The coach must select both the students between 90 and 99.
- The coach must select at least 6 students between 40 and 59.
- The coach must not select students between 0 and 9.
- The coach can ignore the data in the table and randomly pick any 11 players.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Question
The problem revolves around the method of team selection. The coach has multiple criteria suggested, some based on specific score ranges and one suggesting random selection. The aim is to decide the \emph{best way} to select the team.
Step 2: Evaluate Each Option
-
Option A: Selecting all students between 80–99 severely limits the pool, excludes capable players outside that band, and might not yield the best team.
-
Option B: Selecting only two students between 90–99 ignores the rest of the team composition. Too restrictive.
-
Option C: Forcing at least 6 students from 40–59 could weaken the team if that segment is not strong overall.
-
Option D: Simply excluding 0–9 does not solve the problem of how to select the best possible 11. It is a negative restriction, not a holistic approach.
-
Option E: By ignoring the restrictive rules and selecting players freely/randomly (with balance and flexibility), the coach can form a more effective team. Since the given conditions are arbitrary and not optimal, this option is better.
Step 3: Conclusion
The most effective choice is to give the coach freedom to select the best mix of players without artificial restrictions. Hence,
Option E is correct.
\[ \text{Correct Answer: (E)} \]
The problem revolves around the method of team selection. The coach has multiple criteria suggested, some based on specific score ranges and one suggesting random selection. The aim is to decide the \emph{best way} to select the team.
Step 2: Evaluate Each Option
-
Option A: Selecting all students between 80–99 severely limits the pool, excludes capable players outside that band, and might not yield the best team.
-
Option B: Selecting only two students between 90–99 ignores the rest of the team composition. Too restrictive.
-
Option C: Forcing at least 6 students from 40–59 could weaken the team if that segment is not strong overall.
-
Option D: Simply excluding 0–9 does not solve the problem of how to select the best possible 11. It is a negative restriction, not a holistic approach.
-
Option E: By ignoring the restrictive rules and selecting players freely/randomly (with balance and flexibility), the coach can form a more effective team. Since the given conditions are arbitrary and not optimal, this option is better.
Step 3: Conclusion
The most effective choice is to give the coach freedom to select the best mix of players without artificial restrictions. Hence,
Option E is correct.
\[ \text{Correct Answer: (E)} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top Questions on Statements and Conclusions
- Select the conclusion that best follows from the statements given below.
Statements:
In a university, some students can speak English and German, but not French.
Some students can speak French and Japanese, but not Korean.
Some students can speak German and Korean, but not Japanese.
Some students can speak English and Japanese, but not Korean.
Conclusions:
I. All students who speak Japanese can speak English.
II. Among the students who speak German, some can speak English and some can speak Korean.
III. Students who speak French can speak German as well.- NPAT - 2025
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Conclusions
- Select the conclusion that best follows from the statement given below.
Statement:
Some mangoes are exported to Europe and most mangoes are consumed in India. In India, some mangoes are used for preparing mango juice and some are used for making jellies. All mangoes are consumed by humans unless they are raw mangoes. All raw mangoes are exported outside India.
Conclusions:
I. All the mangoes exported to Europe are unfit for human consumption.
II. Mango juice can also be prepared with raw mangoes.
III. Most mangoes are consumed in India in the form of mango jelly.
IV. No raw mango was used to prepare jelly.- NPAT - 2025
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Conclusions
- Select the conclusion that best follows from the statement given below.
Statement:
No one who likes to watch baseball likes to watch basketball, and all those who like to watch basketball also like to watch football.
Conclusions:
I. All those who like to watch football like to watch baseball.
II. No one who likes to watch baseball likes to watch football.
III. Some of those who like to watch football like to watch baseball.- NPAT - 2025
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Conclusions
- Select the conclusion that best follows from the statement given below.
Statement:
In a library, some members were issued non-fiction non-academic books and these were returned exactly 3 weeks later. Some members were issued non-academic fiction books written by American authors and they returned these books within 20 days. More than half the members were issued academic textbooks and these were returned after 20 days.
Conclusions:
I. The non-academic fiction books were borrowed by library members for the shortest duration.
II. Most library members prefer to read non-academic non-fiction books.
III. Academic textbooks were perhaps the most issued books in the library.
IV. Non-academic fiction books are preferred more than the non-academic non-fiction books by library members.- NPAT - 2025
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Conclusions
- Two statements followed by two conclusions are given. Taking the given statements to be true even if they seem to be at variance from commonly known facts, read all the conclusions and then decide which of the given conclusions logically follow from the statements. Statements: 1. Some animals are mammals.
2. All animals are not herbivorous.
Conclusions: I. Some animals are herbivorous.
II. All animals are mammals.- KLEE - 2024
- Arithmetic and Mental Ability
- Statements and Conclusions
View More Questions
Questions Asked in XAT exam
- In an 8-week course, the teacher conducts a test every week, and the scores are in the range of 1–4. There are only two students enrolled in the course, \(R\) and \(S\). The following conditions are given:
- \(R\) and \(S\) scored the same on the first test.
- From the second test onwards, \(R\) consistently scored the same (a non-zero score).
- The total of the first three test scores of \(R\) equals the total of the first two test scores of \(S\).
- From the fifth test onwards, \(S\) scored the same as \(R\).
- The scores of \(S\) from the first two tests and all the remaining tests follow a geometric progression.
- XAT - 2025
- Algebra
- Arya, a graduate from a reputable institute, got a job in an IT company but became bored after a year. Her best friend S, who worked at the same company, joined a top-tier B-school for an MBA, which tempted Arya to pursue the same path. Her friend assured her that an MBA would boost her career prospects and salary. Arya started preparing for an MBA while continuing her job, but the challenge of balancing preparation with work made her consider leaving the job.
- XAT - 2025
- Analytical Decision Making
- There’s a community 30 km outside of the main city. Mr. S started a grocery business in the community after winning the bid by offering way above the rent initially drafted by the community council. The community council, led by Mr. D, agreed to the offer with a performance review every three years. Mr. S also agreed to provide an additional 15% of his grocery sales to the council, banking on the prospect of selling in higher volumes. After setting up his business, Mr. S noticed that SUV owners in the community usually bought goods in bulk from the city once a week and used his store primarily for daily necessities and occasional big purchases like mixer grinders.
- XAT - 2025
- Analytical Decision Making
- Four reviewers (R1, R2, R3, R4) are in charge of reviewing products from companies A, B, C, and D. Each reviewer provides a rating between 1 and 5 for the products. Due to a technical glitch, the original ratings were deleted, and only the averages calculated for each product (A, B, C, D) and each reviewer (R1, R2, R3, R4) were saved. The data available is as follows:Tasks:
A B C D Average 3 4 4 ? 4 3 ? 5 ? 4 ? 3 3 ? 4 ? ? ? ? 4.25 4 4 4 4.25
1. What are the missing values in the table?
2. How were the missing values calculated?
3.Verify the correctness of the given averages for both rows and columns. - A bought a phone from a store and paid \(\frac{1}{6}\) of the price using UPI, \(\frac{1}{3}\) of the price in cash, and the remaining balance a year later. He also paid 10% interest on the remaining balance after one year. What was the original price of the phone?
- XAT - 2025
- Percentage
View More Questions