Question:
Statements:
All players are smokers.
Some smokers are wine-addicts.
Conclusions:
I. All smokers are players.
II. Some wine-addicts are smokers.
Statements:
All players are smokers.
Some smokers are wine-addicts.
Conclusions:
I. All smokers are players.
II. Some wine-addicts are smokers.
All players are smokers.
Some smokers are wine-addicts.
Conclusions:
I. All smokers are players.
II. Some wine-addicts are smokers.
Updated On: Sep 25, 2024
- If only conclusion I follows
- If only conclusion II follows
- If both the conclusions follow
- If neither I nor II follows
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is D
Solution and Explanation
The correct option is (D):
Explanation: From the statements, we know that all players are smokers, but this does not imply that all smokers are players; hence, conclusion I does not follow. Conclusion II states that some wine-addicts are smokers, which is possible but not guaranteed by the statements. Therefore, since neither conclusion is definitively supported by the statements, the correct answer is D – neither I nor II follows.
Explanation: From the statements, we know that all players are smokers, but this does not imply that all smokers are players; hence, conclusion I does not follow. Conclusion II states that some wine-addicts are smokers, which is possible but not guaranteed by the statements. Therefore, since neither conclusion is definitively supported by the statements, the correct answer is D – neither I nor II follows.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top Questions on Syllogisms
- If no scholars are athletes, and some athletes are musicians, can we infer that no scholars are musicians?
- If every candidate who completes the training program gets a job, and Tom got a job, can we conclude that Tom completed the training program?
- If some employees are satisfied with their jobs, and all satisfied employees are productive, can we infer that some employees are productive?
- If all MBA students are ambitious, and some ambitious people are not MBA students, can we infer that some MBA students are not ambitious?
- If no graduates are unemployed, and some unemployed people are not graduates, can we conclude that some graduates are employed?
View More Questions
Questions Asked in MAT exam
- In the following sentence, a part of the sentence is underlined. Beneath each sentence four different ways of phrasing the underlined part are indicated. Choose the best alternative among the four options.
There \(\underline {\text{have}\ \text{been}\ \text{heavy}\ \text{rainfall}}\) yesterday- MAT - 2018
- Sentence Correction
- Who among the following cannot be impeached?
- MAT - 2018
- Politics and Government
- Who is leading the LTTE delegation for the peace process with Sri Lanka?
- MAT - 2018
- International Organizations
- Who was the first UN Secretary General?
- MAT - 2018
- Politics and Government
- Which of the following sources yields the maximum revenue to the Union Government?
- MAT - 2018
- Politics and Government
View More Questions