Question

In the options given below Suman is watching the sunrise. What would be the most appropriate rendering of this scene?

• A. A
• B. B
• C. C
• D. D

Hint:

When evaluating artistic renderings, first identify the primary light source. Then, check for consistency in highlights, shadows, and color temperature. Shadows should always be cast away from the light source.

Answer 1

The Correct Option is C

Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
The question asks for the most appropriate rendering of a sunrise scene. This requires an understanding of how light and shadow work. During sunrise, the sun is low on the horizon, acting as a strong, directional light source coming from the window.

Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
We need to analyze the lighting in each option:

Light Source: The sun is outside the window, so the light should primarily enter from the window.
Light Quality: Sunrise light is typically warm (yellow, orange) and creates high contrast with long, distinct shadows.
Scene Elements: The side of Suman facing the window should be brightly lit. The parts of the room and her body away from the window should be in shadow. A shadow of her form should be cast on the wall behind her.
Let's evaluate the options based on these principles:

Option A: The lighting is too diffuse and flat. There are no strong shadows, which is inconsistent with a direct light source like the sun.
Option B: A shadow is shown, but it is cast towards the window, which is incorrect. The shadow should be cast away from the light source.
Option C: This rendering is the most accurate. The light coming from the window is warm and bright. It correctly illuminates the side of Suman's face and body. A distinct shadow is cast on the wall behind her, away from the window. The rest of the room is appropriately dark, showing high contrast.
Option D: The lighting on Suman is plausible, but the background wall is too brightly and evenly lit. With a strong light source from the window, the back wall should be in shadow.

Step 3: Final Answer:
Option C provides the most realistic and appropriate rendering of lighting and shadow for a sunrise scene.