Question

Explain the prisoner’s arguments for refusing to leave the prison even after being set free.

Hint:

When answering character-based questions, explain both the character’s emotions and the deeper moral message of the story.

Answer 1

Concept: This question is based on the play \textit{“The Bishop’s Candlesticks”} by Norman McKinnel (adapted from Victor Hugo’s work). The character of the convict undergoes a moral transformation after experiencing the Bishop’s kindness.
Step 1: {\color{red}The prisoner’s fear and distrust of society.
The convict argues that society has always treated him cruelly. He was imprisoned for stealing a loaf of bread and was sentenced to many years of harsh punishment. Even after his release, people treated him with suspicion and hatred. Because of this, he believes that society will never accept him. \medskip
Step 2: {\color{red}His belief that prison is his only home.
The prisoner feels that prison has become his true home. After spending many years behind bars, he has become accustomed to chains and hard labor. Outside prison, he sees no hope, dignity, or acceptance. Therefore, he initially prefers to return to prison rather than face rejection and suffering again. \medskip
Step 3: {\color{red}Inner conflict and transformation.
Although he claims that prison is better, his refusal also reveals his inner pain and loss of faith in humanity. However, the Bishop’s compassion and forgiveness eventually change his outlook. The Bishop’s kindness restores his faith and gives him hope for a new life. \medskip Final Answer: The prisoner refuses to leave because he feels rejected and mistreated by society. He believes that prison is the only place where he belongs and that he will never be accepted outside. His arguments reflect his bitterness and despair, but the Bishop’s kindness ultimately transforms his heart and gives him the courage to begin a new life.