As an example of the devastation wrought on music publishers by the photocopier, one executive noted that for a recent choral festival with 1,200 singers, the festival's organizing committee purchased only 12 copies of the music published by her company that was performed as part of the festival.
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the support the example lends to the executive's contention that music publishers have been devastated by the photocopier?
Which of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the support the example lends to the executive's contention that music publishers have been devastated by the photocopier?
Show Hint
- Only a third of the 1,200 singers were involved in performing the music published by the executive's company.
- Half of the singers at the festival had already heard the music they were to perform before they began to practice for the festival.
- Because of shortages in funding, the organizing committee of the choral festival required singers to purchase their own copies of the music performed at the festival.
- Each copy of music that was performed at the festival was shared by two singers.
- As a result of publicity generated by its performance at the festival, the type of music performed at the festival became more widely known.
The Correct Option is C
Solution and Explanation
This is a weaken the argument question. The executive's argument consists of a conclusion and a piece of evidence.
Conclusion: Music publishers have been devastated by the photocopier.
Evidence: For a festival with 1,200 singers, the organizing committee bought only 12 copies of music.
Assumption: The executive assumes that the only reason for the low sales number (12) relative to the number of participants (1,200) is that the remaining copies were illegally photocopied. To weaken the argument, we must attack this assumption by providing a plausible alternative explanation for the low sales figure.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
We need to find an answer choice that explains why the committee might have bought only 12 copies, even if no photocopying took place.
Analyzing the Options:
(A) If only a third of the singers (400) performed the music, there is still a massive discrepancy between 400 singers and 12 copies sold. This does not seriously weaken the assumption that photocopying occurred.
(B) Having heard the music is irrelevant to needing the physical sheet music to perform it in a choir.
(C) This provides a compelling alternative explanation. If the committee's policy was to require singers to buy their own copies, then the committee itself would only need a few reference copies (e.g., for the conductor, accompanists, etc.). The 12 copies sold to the committee would not represent the total sales for the festival. Many more copies could have been sold directly to the 1,200 singers. This breaks the link between the evidence (12 copies sold to the committee) and the conclusion (devastation by photocopier), thus seriously weakening the argument.
(D) If each copy was shared by two singers, then 600 copies would be needed for 1,200 singers. The sale of only 12 copies would actually strengthen the executive's claim that massive photocopying must have occurred.
(E) This discusses a potential positive outcome after the festival, which is irrelevant to why so few copies were sold for the festival itself.
Step 3: Final Answer:
Option (C) provides the strongest alternative reason for the low number of sales to the organizing committee, thereby weakening the executive's claim that photocopying is the cause.
Top Questions on Critical Reasoning
- A study shows that employees who work from home tend to be more productive. A company is considering allowing employees to work from home at least three days a week. Which of the following, if true, would most strengthen the company's argument?
- GMAT - 2025
- Verbal Reasoning
- Critical Reasoning
- The director of a museum claims that visitors will be more likely to attend an exhibition if it is promoted through social media. Which of the following assumptions is necessary for the director's claim to be valid?
- GMAT - 2025
- Verbal Reasoning
- Critical Reasoning
- A study suggests that a new drug will help reduce symptoms of a certain illness. Which of the following, if true, would most strengthen the study's conclusion?
- GMAT - 2025
- Verbal Reasoning
- Critical Reasoning
- A recent study claims that reading books increases intelligence. Which of the following would most weaken the argument?
- GMAT - 2025
- Verbal Reasoning
- Critical Reasoning
- A company claims that its employees work better when they have flexible hours. Which of the following, if true, would most reveal a flaw in the company's reasoning?
- GMAT - 2025
- Verbal Reasoning
- Critical Reasoning
Questions Asked in GRE exam
In early-twentieth-century England, it was fashionable to claim that only a completely new style of writing could address a world undergoing unprecedented transformation — just as one literary critic recently claimed that only the new ”aesthetic of exploratory excess” can address a world undergoing . . . well, you know. Yet in early-twentieth-century England, T. S. Eliot, a man fascinated by the ”presence” of the past, wrote the most innovative poetry of his time. The lesson for today’s literary community seems obvious: a reorientation toward tradition would benefit writers no less than readers. But if our writers and critics indeed respect the novel’s rich tradition (as they claim to), then why do they disdain the urge to tell an exciting story?
- GRE - 2024
- Reading Comprehension
In the 1970’s, two debates engaged many scholars of early United States history. One focused on the status of women, primarily White women. Turning on the so-called golden age the ory, which posited that during the eighteenth-century colonial era, American women enjoyed a brief period of high status relative to their English contemporaries and to nineteenth-century American women, this debate pitted scholars who believed women’s lives deteriorated after 1800 against those who thought women’s lives had been no better before 1800. At issue were the causes of women’s subordination: were these causes already in place when the English first settled North America or did they emerge with the rise of nineteenth-century industrial capital ism? The second debate, the so-called origins debate, concerned the emergence of racial slavery in the southern colonies: was slavery the inevitable result of the deep-rooted racial prejudice of early British colonists or did racial prejudice arise only after these planters instituted slave labor?
Although these debates are parallel in some respects, key differences distinguished them. Whereas the debate over women’s status revolved around implicit comparisons of colonial women to their counterparts in the antebellum period (1800-1860), thus inviting comment from scholars of both historical periods, the origins debate was primarily confined to a discussion about slavery in colonial America. Second, in contrast to the newness of the debate over women’s status and its continued currency throughout the early 1980’s, the debate over race and slavery, begun in the 1950’s, had lost some of its urgency with the publication of Morgan’s American Slavery, American Freedom (1975), widely regarded as the last word on the subject. Each debate also assumed a different relationship to the groups whose histories it concerned. In its heyday, the origins debate focused mainly on White attitudes toward Africans rather than on Africans themselves. With few exceptions, such as Wood’s Black Majority (1974) and Mullin’s Flight and Rebellion (1972), which were centrally concerned with enslaved African men, most works pertaining to the origins debate focused on the White architects, mostly male, of racial slavery. In contrast, although women’s historians were interested in the institutions and ide ologies contributing to women’s subordination, they were equally concerned with documenting women’s experiences. As in the origins debate, however, early scholarship on colonial women defined its historical constituency narrowly, women’s historians focusing mainly on affluent White women.
Over time, however, some initial differences between the approaches taken by scholars in the two fields faded. In the 1980’s, historians of race and slavery in colonial America shifted their attention to enslaved people; interest in African American culture grew, thereby bringing en slaved women more prominently into view. Historians of early American women moved in similar directions during the decade and began to consider the effect of racial difference on women’s experience.- GRE - 2024
- Reading Comprehension
The most plausible justification for higher taxes on automobile fuel is that fuel consumption harms the environment and thus adds to the costs of traffic congestion. But the fact that burning fuel creates these ”negative externalities” does not imply that no tax on fuel could ever be too high. Economics is precise about the tax that should, in principle, be levied to deal with negative externalities: the tax on a liter of fuel should be equal to the harm caused by using a liter of fuel. If the tax is more than that, its costs (including the inconvenience to those who would rather have used their cars) will exceed its benefits (including any reduction in congestion and pollution).
- GRE - 2024
- Reading Comprehension
Objectively, of course, the various ecosystems that sustain life on the planet proceed independently of human agency, just as they operated before the hectic ascendancy of Homo sapiens. But it is also true that it is difficult to think of a single such system that has not, for better or worse, been substantially modified by human culture. Nor is this simply the work of the industrial centuries. It has been happening since the days of ancient Mesopotamia. It is coeval with the origins of writing, and has occurred throughout our social existence. And it is this irreversibly modified world, from the polar caps to the equatorial forests, that is all the nature we have.
- GRE - 2024
- Reading Comprehension
Music critics have consistently defined James P. Johnson as a great early jazz pianist, originator of the 1920’s Harlem ”stride” style, and an important blues and jazz composer. In addition, however, Johnson was an innovator in classical music, composing symphonic music that incor porated American, and especially African American, traditions.
Such a blend of musical elements was not entirely new: by 1924 both Milhaud and Gershwin had composed classical works that incorporated elements of jazz. Johnson, a serious musician more experienced than most classical composers with jazz, blues, spirituals, and popular music, was particularly suited to expand Milhaud’s and Gershwin’s experiments. In 1927 he completed his first large-scale work, the blues- and jazz-inspired Yamekraw, which included borrowings from spirituals and Johnson’s own popular songs. Yamekraw, premiered successfully in Carnegie Hall, was a major achievement for Johnson, becoming his most frequently performed extended work. It demonstrated vividly the possibility of assimilating contemporary popular music into the symphonic tradition.- GRE - 2024
- Reading Comprehension