Although Apple products have continued to enjoy record-breaking profits worldwide, iPod retailers have recently reported that the numbers of the touch-screen devices sold have steadily decreased in the past two years. However, in the past two years, the numbers of iPhones sold have nearly doubled. Thus, more people are choosing to buy iPhones than iPods when selecting from Apple's products.
The reasoning in the argument is questionable primarily because the argument:
The reasoning in the argument is questionable primarily because the argument:
Show Hint
- assumes an inherent preference in people for one product over another.
- lacks specific numbers to bolster the conclusion.
- doesn't admit alternative explanations for the situation.
- suggests iPod retailers and iPhone retailers are one and the same.
- limits the scope of its argument to only two of Apple's products.
The Correct Option is C
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the flaw in the argument.
The argument assumes that the increase in iPhone sales is directly related to a preference for iPhones over iPods, but it doesn't consider other possible factors, such as changes in product marketing, pricing, or customer demographics.
Step 2: Analysis of options.
- (A) The argument doesn't assume an inherent preference for one product over the other, but it assumes the cause of the sales difference is iPhone preference.
- (B) While lacking specific numbers is a concern, the main issue is the failure to consider alternative explanations for the trend.
- (C) The argument doesn't explore other possible reasons for the shift in sales, such as marketing, pricing, or availability, which makes this the best answer.
- (D) The argument doesn't imply that iPod retailers and iPhone retailers are the same; it's focused on product sales, not retail specifics.
- (E) The scope is not limited to just two products but focuses on a sales trend involving two Apple products.
Step 3: Conclusion.
The correct answer is (C) because the flaw in reasoning is the failure to account for alternative explanations for the change in sales numbers.
Top Questions on Statements and Assumptions
Business schools’ (B schools) curriculums are filled with group assignments and case competitions. Even when students have just joined the B schools, corporate houses try 38 to catch good talent early by promising them internships based on case competitions. These competitions involve solving the problems presented by the organizations, analyzing the challenges they currently face, and presenting solutions in a manner that convinces the organizations’ representatives.
For students who are just joining a B school, the capability to actually solve such problems is quite limited. Because of that, the corporate houses generally are more focused on the presentations made by groups. Hence, the groups that communicate better, most often, win these competitions.
Abirami joins MBS, a B school. As a fresher, she believes she needs to learn a lot about how organizations work and wants to work with others who have joined MBS and have work experience.- XAT - 2026
- Decision Making
- Statements and Assumptions
- Mr. Screwwala, a highly successful investment banker, had a career of nearly 25 years. In his circle, he was respected for his straight-shooter image and industrious behaviour. Screwwala loved travelling; he travelled extensively, both for his job and personal interests. He always wanted to share his life experiences with people at large.
He chanced upon such an opportunity when his old friend, Mr. Patel, a well-known publisher, offered Screwwala to publish a book based on his life experiences. Screwwala grabbed the opportunity; however, given his thorough nature, he took a three-year long sabbatical to finish the book.
During that period, Patel guided Screwwala at every step, reviewing every chapter personally. At the end, the book turned out to be a bestseller, and Screwwala became famous.
Patel had a new proposal for Screwwala: he wanted Screwwala to work on a detective novel. Patel promised him good money but proposed that Screwwala would only write the final chapter of the novel, after his co-authors had completed the first nine chapters. Screwwala was surprised at the offer; since he never tried writing anything creative, and definitely not fiction. He wanted to be sure whether he could actually measure up with the co-authors who were established creative writers.- XAT - 2026
- Decision Making
- Statements and Assumptions
An examination is taken by three kinds of students: Diligent (10%), Lazy (30%) and Confused (60%). Diligent students are 10 times as likely to pass the exam as Lazy students. If 40% of the students who passed the exam are Confused, what is the maximum possible probability that a Confused student passes the exam?
- XAT - 2026
- Decision Making
- Statements and Assumptions
- Recycling bins are placed in a mall and trash volume falls. Which assumption is necessary to claim recycling caused the drop?
- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2026
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Assumptions
- A company switches to a 4-day workweek and observes no productivity drop. Leaders claim the schedule is efficient. Which assumption is needed to support the leaders' claim?
- AILET BALLB (Hons.) - 2026
- Logical Reasoning
- Statements and Assumptions
Questions Asked in GMAT exam
- If Lynn can type a page in p minutes, what piece of the page can she do in 5 minutes?
- GMAT - 2025
- Ratio and Proportion
- Find out if t < 0.
1. \(|t|>t\)
2. \(t^2>0\)- GMAT - 2025
- Data Sufficiency
- Is the number a prime number?
1. The number is divisible by a prime factor.
2. The number is positive.- GMAT - 2025
- Data Sufficiency
- Find the equation of a line.
1. Its x and y intercept is 2 and -2 respectively.
2. The slope of the line is 1.- GMAT - 2025
- Data Sufficiency
- Find the area of a right angle triangle whose base is 12 inches.
1. The hypotenuse is 13 inches.
2. The perpendicular height of the triangle is one less than half its base.- GMAT - 2025
- Data Sufficiency