Question

A species of fish living in a lake are separated by drying up of the lake into two separate lakes. After several hundreds of years of separation, the two groups are unable to mate. These groups are now considered to be different _____.

• A. communities
• B. organisms
• C. populations
• D. species

Answer 1

The Correct Option is D

The question centers around the concept of speciation, which is a fundamental concept in evolutionary biology. Here, we are examining a situation where a population of fish has been divided into two separate groups due to geographical isolation—the lake drying up into two separate bodies of water. Over time, these groups have diverged enough that they can no longer interbreed, meaning they have become distinct species.

1. Initially, the fish were part of the same population in a single lake. Due to an environmental change, the lake dries up, splitting into two, leading to geographical isolation of the fish.
2. When two groups of the same species are separated geographically for extended periods, they undergo divergence due to mutation, natural selection, and genetic drift operating independently in the two groups.
3. After several hundreds of years, these separate groups develop reproductive isolating mechanisms preventing them from mating with each other. This could include behavioral changes, ecological adaptations, or physiological differences.
4. According to the Biological Species Concept, a species is defined by the ability to interbreed and produce fertile offspring. Since these fish can no longer interbreed, they represent two separate species.

The correct answer is species because the inability to mate and produce viable offspring signifies speciation. This process results in the development of distinct species under the principle of reproductive isolation.

To clarify why other options are incorrect:

• Communities: This term refers to different species living together in a common environment interacting with each other, not to diverged groups of the same species.
• Organisms: This term is too broad as it refers to any living individual entity, not specifically a group classification such as species.
• Populations: Although this term could describe groups within a species in a given area, the question describes these groups as reproductively isolated, qualifying them as separate species.