Question:

Statement :
The doctor is of the opinion that the patient’s condition would become normal after this operation.

Conclusions: I. The patient’s condition is such that he can be operated upon.
II. Certain costly medicines can be administered to the patient and the operation may not be necessary.

Show Hint

When evaluating conclusions based on a statement, ensure that the reasoning is directly supported by the information given. If the statement specifically indicates a course of action, conclusions suggesting alternatives that are not mentioned should be discarded.
Updated On: Mar 9, 2025
  • if conclusion I follows
  • if conclusion II follows
  • if neither conclusion I follows nor II follows
  • if both conclusions I and II follow
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

The statement provided says that "The doctor is of the opinion that the patient’s condition would become normal after this operation." From this, we can infer the following:
- Conclusion I: The patient’s condition is such that he can be operated upon.
This conclusion follows from the statement. The doctor is suggesting that an operation is necessary to restore the patient’s condition to normal, which implicitly means the patient’s condition is operable. Thus, Conclusion I is valid.

- Conclusion II: Certain costly medicines can be administered to the patient and the operation may not be necessary.
This conclusion does not follow from the statement. The doctor specifically believes that the patient's condition will improve after the operation, without suggesting that expensive medicines could eliminate the need for surgery. Therefore, Conclusion II is not supported by the statement.
Since only Conclusion I is valid, the correct answer is (1).
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Questions Asked in MAT exam

View More Questions