Comprehension
Read the poem carefully and answer the TWO questions that follow.
It hurts to walk on new legs: 
The curse of consonants. The wobble of vowels. 
And you for whom I gave up a kingdom 
Can never love that thing I was. 
When you look into my past 
You see 
Only weeds and scales. 
Once I had a voice. 
Now I have legs. 
Sometimes I wonder 
Was it a fair trade?
Question: 1

Which of the following statements BEST reflects the theme of the poem?

Updated On: Dec 18, 2025
  • Our quest for love is accompanied with pain.
  • Nostalgic recollection undermines materialistic gains.
  • Our loss of identity is irreparable.
  • As the future unfolds, our distant past looks pleasant.
  • Our concern for loss is more than what we gain.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Approach Solution - 1

The poem presents a scenario where the speaker reflects on the transformative experience they have undergone for the sake of love. This transformation is metaphorically described through a change from having a 'voice' to having 'legs.' Let's break down the poem's theme based on the given context:

  1. The speaker mentions giving up a 'kingdom' for 'you,' suggesting a significant sacrifice related to love.
  2. The phrase "curse of consonants" and "wobble of vowels" symbolizes the struggle and pain associated with adapting to a new situation or identity.
  3. There is a sense of regret or questioning about this transformation, evident from the line "Was it a fair trade?" indicating doubt and pain accompanying the change.
  4. The speaker notes that the person they transformed for "can never love that thing I was," revealing the personal loss suffered in the quest for this love.

The correct theme, therefore, is centered around the quest for love being accompanied by pain, resonating most with the provided option:

  • Correct Option: Our quest for love is accompanied with pain.

This option encapsulates the essence of the poem where love demands significant changes, bringing about a certain sadness or loss.

Let's briefly analyze why the other options are not as suitable:

  • Nostalgic recollection undermines materialistic gains: This notion doesn't align with the poem, as there is more emphasis on emotional and identity loss rather than materialistic aspects.
  • Our loss of identity is irreparable: While the poem does touch on identity transformation, the essence is more about love and its accompanying pain than the finality of identity loss.
  • As the future unfolds, our distant past looks pleasant: This isn't directly addressed in the poem; the focus remains on present pain from past sacrifices, rather than a comparison of past and future pleasures.
  • Our concern for loss is more than what we gain: This option is plausible but less explicitly dealt with than the theme of love's painful quest.

Thus, the main theme presented in the poem is effectively conveyed through the option "Our quest for love is accompanied with pain."

Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

Approach Solution -2

The central theme of the poem revolves around the search for love, which is portrayed as a deep human longing. However, this pursuit does not come without challenges — it is often intertwined with suffering, sacrifice, and disappointment. Thus, the poem highlights the paradox of love: it gives meaning and joy, but also brings pain and struggle.

Why Option 1 is Best 

  • It directly expresses the core emotional conflict — the intertwining of love and pain.
  • It is broad enough to encompass the emotional, personal, and reflective aspects of the poem.

Why Other Options Are Incorrect

  • Option 2: Focuses on nostalgia vs. materialism, which is not the poem’s theme.
  • Option 3: Loss of identity is not the central concern of the poem.
  • Option 4: Talks about past vs. future, but the poem is more about love and pain.
  • Option 5: Overgeneralizes loss vs. gain; does not directly capture the theme of love’s struggles.

Key Takeaway

The poem reflects the duality of love: it is both a source of joy and a cause of pain. Thus, the best thematic statement is: “Our quest for love is accompanied with pain.”

Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2

What does the author BEST mean by “Once I had a voice. /Now I have legs?”

Updated On: Dec 18, 2025
  • The poet puts less value on the new world
  • The poet is contemplative of his/her identity
  • The poet’s actions speak louder than his/her words now
  • The poet is indecisive about choosing between the two worlds
  • The poet has lost his/her speech
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is B

Approach Solution - 1

To analyze the statement "Once I had a voice. / Now I have legs," we need to consider the poet's contemplation of change in identity and purpose. Let’s go through the excerpt from the poem to understand the context:

  1. The poem opens with the author expressing difficulty with "new legs," symbolizing a transition or change.
  2. References such as "The curse of consonants. The wobble of vowels." suggest challenges in speech or communication.
  3. The transition from "I had a voice" to "Now I have legs" signifies a move from being expressive (having a 'voice,' likely metaphorical for expression or influence) to taking actions or exploring new terrains ('having legs').
  4. Through the line "Was it a fair trade?" the poet reflects on whether gaining the ability to take action (legs) but potentially losing expressiveness and voice was beneficial.
  5. The option "The poet is contemplative of his/her identity" best encapsulates the poet's introspective evaluation of their change in identity and capacity.

Now, let's rule out the other options:

  • The poet puts less value on the new world: While the challenges of this new state are discussed, it's more about contemplation rather than valuing one state over the other.
  • The poet’s actions speak louder than his/her words now: This might seem a logical fit due to "Now I have legs," however, the poem is introspective rather than indicative of loud actions superseding words.
  • The poet is indecisive about choosing between the two worlds: There is a reflection on the change, not indecision.
  • The poet has lost his/her speech: The loss of a literal voice isn’t the central theme; it's a metaphorical evolution rather than an actual loss of speech.

In conclusion, the best interpretation of "Once I had a voice. / Now I have legs" in the poem is that the poet is contemplative of his/her identity as they reflect on the transformative experience and reconcile their past expressive self with their current active state.

Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

Approach Solution -2

The poetic line “Once I had a voice. / Now I have legs” uses symbolism to show a transformation of identity. Here:

  • “Voice” symbolizes expression, individuality, or inner identity.
  • “Legs” symbolizes movement, adaptation, or survival in a new world.

The poet reflects on how their sense of self has changed — they once defined themselves through expression and voice, but now they define themselves through action, adaptation, and existence. This shift leads to contemplation of identityWho am I now, compared to who I was before?

Why Option 2 is Best 

  • It captures the introspective nature of the line — thinking about past vs. present identity.
  • Other options are too narrow (e.g., losing speech, indecision, or undervaluing the world) and miss the deeper theme of self-reflection.

Key Takeaway

The author’s lines emphasize a shift in identity and self-awareness. Thus, the best interpretation is that the poet is contemplative of his/her identityOption 2.

Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Questions Asked in XAT exam

View More Questions