Question

Given below are two statements : Statement I : Carcinosin is indicated in post operative gas pains, no relief from passing it. Statement II : Children have great fear, are sensitive to reprimands but sympathetic to others is a characteristic feature of Carcinosin. In the light of the above statements, choose the most appropriate answer from the options given below :

• A. \( \text{Both Statement I and Statement II are correct} \)
• B. \( \text{Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect} \)
• C. \( \text{Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect} \)
• D. \( \text{Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct} \)

Hint:

\textbf{Homeopathy: Carcinosinum.} Remember that *Carcinosinum* is a nosode with a complex symptom picture, often involving a history of cancer in the family. Key mental-emotional traits include sensitivity, anxiety, a love of travel and dancing, and a sympathetic nature.

Answer 1

The Correct Option is D

Let's analyze each statement regarding the homeopathic remedy *Carcinosinum*: Statement I: Carcinosin is indicated in post operative gas pains, no relief from passing it. While *Carcinosinum* can be used for a wide range of complaints, including gastrointestinal issues, it is not a primary or specifically well-known remedy for post-operative gas pains that are unrelieved by passing flatus. Other remedies like *Nux vomica*, *Carbo vegetabilis*, or *Colocynthis* are more typically considered for such symptoms. Therefore, Statement I is likely incorrect. Statement II: Children have great fear, are sensitive to reprimands but sympathetic to others is a characteristic feature of Carcinosin. This statement accurately reflects key emotional and behavioral characteristics often associated with the *Carcinosinum* type, particularly in children. They can exhibit deep-seated fears, be very sensitive to criticism or reprimands, and yet possess a strong sense of empathy and sympathy towards others. This combination of sensitivity and compassion is a notable aspect of the *Carcinosinum* personality. Therefore, Statement II is correct. In conclusion, Statement I is incorrect, but Statement II is correct.