Comprehension

Analyse the following passage and provide appropriate answers that follow. 
We can answer Fermi’s Paradox in two ways. Perhaps our current science over - estimates the likelihood of extraterrestrial intelligence evolving. Or, perhaps, evolved technical intelligence has some deep tendency to be self - limiting, even self - exterminating. After Hiroshima, some suggested that any aliens bright enough to make colonizing space ships would be bright enough to make thermonuclear bombs, and would use them on each other sooner or later.
I suggest a different, even darker solution to the Paradox. Basically, I think the aliens forget to send radio signals or colonize space because they’re too busy with runaway consumerism and virtual - reality narcissism. Once they turn inwards to chase their shiny pennies of pleasure, they lose the cosmic plot.
The fundamental problem is that an evolved mind must pay attention to indirect cues of biological tness, rather than tracking tness itself. This was a key insight of evolutionary psychology in the early 1990s; although evolution favours brains that tend to maximize tness (as measured by numbers of great - grandkids), no brain has capacity enough to do so under every possible circumstance. As a result, brains must evolve shortcuts: tness - promoting tricks, cons, recipes and heuristics that work, on an average, under ancestrally normal conditions. Technology is fairly good at controlling external reality to promote real biological tness, but it’s even better at delivering fake tness - subjective cues of survival and reproduction without the real - world effects.
Fitness - faking technology tends to evolve much faster than our psychological resistance to it. With the invention of Xbox 360, people would rather play a high - resolution virtual ape in Peter Jackson’s King Kong than be a perfect – resolution real human. Teens today must nd their way through a carnival of addictively tness faking entertainment products. The traditional staples of physical, mental and social development - athletics, homework dating - are neglected. The few young people with the self - control to pursue the meritocratic path often get distracted at the last minute.
Around 1900, most inventions concerned physical reality and in 2005 focus shifted to virtual entertainment. Freud’s pleasure principle triumphs over the reality principle. Today we narrow - cast human - interest stories to each other, rather than broadcasting messages of universal peace and progress to other star systems. Maybe the bright aliens did the same. I suspect that a certain period of tness - faking narcissism is inevitable after any intelligent life evolves. This is the Great Temptation for any technological species – to shape their subjective reality to provide the cues of survival and reproductive success without the substance. Most bright alien species probably go extinct gradually, allocating more time and resources to their pleasures and less to their children.
Heritable variation in personality might allow some lineages to resist the Great Temptation and last longer. Some individuals and families may start with an “irrational” Luddite abhorrence of entertainment technology, and they may evolve ever more self - control, conscientiousness and pragmatism by combining the family values of the religious right with the sustainability values of the Greenpeace. They wait patiently for our tness faking narcissism to go extinct. Those practical - minded breeders will inherit the Earth as like - minded aliens may have inherited a few other planets. When they nally achieve contacts, it will not be a meeting of novel readers and game - players. It will be a meeting of dead - serious super - parents who congratulate each other on surviving not just the Bomb, but the Xbox.

Question: 1

Among the following options, which one represents the most important concern raised in the passage?

Show Hint

When a passage provides multiple scientific ideas, focus on the recurring theme. Here, “pleasure seeking” appeared several times, showing it is the author’s main concern.
Updated On: Aug 23, 2025
  • Extraterrestrial life and its impact on human beings.
  • Lack of interest in developing proper fitness.
  • Short-term pleasure seeking behaviour.
  • Technological advancement and extinction of intelligence.
  • Tendency of brain to develop shortcuts.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is C

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Identify the passage’s core concern.
The passage focuses on how technological advancement leads humans (and possibly aliens) into a phase of \emph{fitness-faking narcissism}, where they chase short-term pleasures instead of genuine development.

Step 2: Eliminate other options.
- (A) Extraterrestrial life is mentioned but only as context; not the main concern. ✗
- (B) Lack of fitness is secondary; the real issue is why fitness is being ignored. ✗
- (C) Pleasure-seeking behaviour is directly emphasized as the main danger. ✓
- (D) Extinction of intelligence is implied, but as a consequence, not the central issue. ✗
- (E) Brain shortcuts are explained scientifically, but they support, not replace, the main concern. ✗


Step 3: Conclude.
The author stresses that short-term pleasure seeking is the most important concern for both humans and hypothetical aliens. \[ \boxed{\text{Short-term pleasure seeking behaviour (C)}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2

Which among the following would be the best possible explanation for the lack of contact between human beings and aliens?

Show Hint

In RC passages on scientific theories, the correct answer usually matches the author’s unique viewpoint rather than general scientific possibilities.
Updated On: Aug 23, 2025
  • Overestimation of the technological capability of aliens.
  • Genetic variation in aliens’ personality is not yet achieved.
  • Thermonuclear bombs might have destroyed all aliens.
  • Colonisation of space is impossible to achieve.
  • Aliens have become self-centred and pleasure seeking.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Link the author’s hypothesis.
The author suggests that aliens, like humans, may have fallen victim to “fitness-faking narcissism.” They became obsessed with pleasure, self-centredness, and consumerism, neglecting cosmic exploration.

Step 2: Eliminate weaker explanations.
- (A) Overestimation of capability → Not discussed in passage. ✗
- (B) Genetic variation → Irrelevant here. ✗
- (C) Thermonuclear destruction → Mentioned briefly, but not emphasized. ✗
- (D) Colonisation impossible → Counter to the argument; the passage assumes it’s possible. ✗
- (E) Self-centred, pleasure seeking → Matches author’s main argument directly. ✓


Step 3: Conclude.
The best explanation for alien silence is that they too became indulgent in narcissistic pleasure-seeking, just like humans. \[ \boxed{\text{Aliens have become self-centred and pleasure seeking (E)}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3

To which of the following statements would the author of the passage agree the most?

Show Hint

For “author’s agreement” questions, match the option with the core philosophy expressed. Here, the core was that consumerism distracts from exploration and adventure.
Updated On: Aug 23, 2025
  • Violent crime, including gang warfare for turf protection and expansion, co-exists in all technologically advanced societies in spite of proliferation of fitness-faking technologies.
  • The technology to produce fitness-faking gadgets is guided by the government’s desire to control the minds of citizens and keep citizens away from engaging in trouble-making activities.
  • Countries that have the most advanced technology often are the ones that are at the forefront of colonial expansion through wars.
  • Wars and colonial conquest engaged in by the European nations after the renaissance would not have occurred had fitness-faking gadgets and consumerism existed in those countries during those times.
  • The search for colonies is undertaken by all countries, irrespective of their technological expansion. This colonial expansion is guided more by need for adventure than for resources.
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is D

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Recall the passage’s theme.
The author emphasized that humans in the past were adventurous, scientific, and exploratory. Today’s humans, however, are distracted by fitness-faking consumerism.

Step 2: Apply historical comparison.
If fitness-faking gadgets had existed during Renaissance Europe, people might have been too distracted by entertainment and consumerism to pursue exploration and colonisation.

Step 3: Evaluate options.
- (A) Mentions crime, but unrelated to author’s concern. ✗
- (B) Suggests government conspiracy, not discussed. ✗
- (C) True historically, but the author emphasizes contrast with today, not just a fact about wars. ✗
- (D) Perfectly matches the author’s line of thought about how consumerism prevents exploration. ✓
- (E) Too general and unrelated to the focus of the passage. ✗


Step 4: Conclude.
The author would agree most with the idea that wars and colonial conquests would have been absent if consumerism and fitness-faking distractions existed then. \[ \boxed{\text{Wars and colonial conquest prevented by consumerism (D)}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4

Which of the following statements, if true, challenges the ideas presented in the passage the most? I. Violent crime, including gang warfare for turf protection and expansion, co-exists in all technological advanced societies in spite of proliferation of fitness-faking technologies.
II. The technology to produce fitness-faking gadgets is guided by the government’s desire to control the minds of citizens and keep citizens away from engaging in trouble-making activities.
III. Countries that have the most advanced technology often are the ones that are at the forefront of preparedness for wars.
IV. The era of colonial expansion that was engaged in by the European nations after the renaissance would have never taken place had the technology to produce fitness-faking gadgets existed during those times.
V. Teenagers having access to technology, engage in more socializing away from parental supervision than those who do not have access to such technology.

Show Hint

When asked which statements “challenge” an author, focus on those that directly oppose the \emph{central claim}. Supporting or tangential ideas do not count as strong challenges.
Updated On: Aug 23, 2025
  • I & III
  • II & III
  • III & IV
  • I, II & V
  • I, III & V
Hide Solution
collegedunia
Verified By Collegedunia

The Correct Option is A

Solution and Explanation

Step 1: Recall the central argument of the passage.
The author’s main idea is that technological advancement has made humans (and possibly aliens) \emph{pleasure-seeking and fake-fitness inclined}, distracting them from exploration, wars, or adventurous expansion. In other words, consumerism replaces adventurousness.

Step 2: Test each statement against this core.
-

I. Violent crime still exists in advanced societies: This contradicts the author’s claim that technological advancement makes people inward-focused and distracted by fake pleasures. If violent expansion still occurs despite fitness-faking gadgets, it challenges the passage. ✓
-

II. Government control through gadgets: This is a different explanation, but it does not directly oppose the claim that technology distracts individuals into pleasure-seeking. ✗
-

III. Advanced nations prepare more for wars: This also contradicts the passage because the author argues that technology weakens adventurous/exploratory tendencies, but this statement says it strengthens them. ✓
-

IV. Colonial expansion would not have occurred with gadgets: This actually supports the author’s argument, not challenges it. ✗
-

V. Teenagers socialize more away from parents with technology: This reflects behavioural changes, but it doesn’t counter the claim of pleasure-seeking narcissism. ✗


Step 3: Conclude.
Only statements (I) and (III) directly contradict the author’s thesis by claiming that violence, war, and adventurous expansion continue despite technology. Hence, they challenge the passage most strongly. \[ \boxed{\text{I & III (A)}} \]
Was this answer helpful?
0
0

Top Questions on Reading Comprehension

View More Questions

Questions Asked in XAT exam

View More Questions