Comprehension
A scientist will perform six experiments - P, R, T, X, Y, and z - during a three-month period, August through October. In each of the three months, exactly two of the experiments will be performed. Each experiment will start on the first day of a month and be completed during that month, The order in which the experiments are performed will also be governed by the following restrictions:
R must be performed in August or in September.
T must be performed in September or in October.
T cannot be performed in the same month in which X is performed.
X must be performed in an earlier month than the month in which Z is performed.
Question: 1
Which of the following can be the schedule for the six experiments?
Which of the following can be the schedule for the six experiments?
Show Hint
When checking options, go through the rules systematically. Start with the most concrete rules (like R must be in Aug/Sep) to eliminate choices quickly.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- Aug: P, R | Sep: T, X | Oct: Y, Z
- Aug: R, T | Sep: X, Y | Oct: P, Z
- Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Y | Oct: P, Z
- Aug: X, Y | Sep: P, Z | Oct: R, T
- Aug: Y, Z | Sep: R, T | Oct: P, X
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is C
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is an "acceptable schedule" question. We need to check each option against the rules until we find one that is valid.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
- (A) Aug: P, R | Sep: T, X | Oct: Y, Z: This violates Rule 3, as T and X are in the same month (September).
- (B) Aug: R, T | Sep: X, Y | Oct: P, Z: This violates Rule 2, as T is in August, but it must be in September or October.
- (C) Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Y | Oct: P, Z: - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): Met, R is in August. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): Met, T is in September. - Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Met, T is in September, X is in August. - Rule 4 (X \textless Z): Met, X is in August, Z is in October. Since all rules are satisfied, this is a valid schedule.
- (D) Aug: X, Y | Sep: P, Z | Oct: R, T: This violates Rule 1, as R is in October, but it must be in August or September.
- (E) Aug: Y, Z | Sep: R, T | Oct: P, X: This violates Rule 4, as X is in October, which is later than Z in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
The only schedule that satisfies all the rules is (C).
This is an "acceptable schedule" question. We need to check each option against the rules until we find one that is valid.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
- (A) Aug: P, R | Sep: T, X | Oct: Y, Z: This violates Rule 3, as T and X are in the same month (September).
- (B) Aug: R, T | Sep: X, Y | Oct: P, Z: This violates Rule 2, as T is in August, but it must be in September or October.
- (C) Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Y | Oct: P, Z: - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): Met, R is in August. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): Met, T is in September. - Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Met, T is in September, X is in August. - Rule 4 (X \textless Z): Met, X is in August, Z is in October. Since all rules are satisfied, this is a valid schedule.
- (D) Aug: X, Y | Sep: P, Z | Oct: R, T: This violates Rule 1, as R is in October, but it must be in August or September.
- (E) Aug: Y, Z | Sep: R, T | Oct: P, X: This violates Rule 4, as X is in October, which is later than Z in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
The only schedule that satisfies all the rules is (C).
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 2
Any of the following experiments can be performed in August EXCEPT
Any of the following experiments can be performed in August EXCEPT
Show Hint
"Cannot be true" or "EXCEPT" questions are often solved by looking at the most restrictive rules, especially those involving relative ordering (like "before" or "after").
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- P
- R
- X
- Y
- Z
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This question asks which experiment can NEVER be in August. We need to check the rules to see which experiment is forbidden from being in the first month.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
The most relevant rule is Rule 4: "X must be performed in an earlier month than the month in which Z is performed."
- This means X must come before Z in the sequence of months. - If Z were in August (the earliest month), there would be no earlier month available for X to be performed in. - Therefore, Z cannot be in August.
To confirm the others are possible in August, we can refer to the valid schedule from question 1: - Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Y | Oct: P, Z - This shows R and X can be in August. We can also easily construct a schedule with P and Y in August. For example: - Aug: P, Y | Sep: R, X | Oct: T, Z. This is valid. So, P, R, X, and Y can all be in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
Z is the only experiment that cannot be performed in August due to the rule that X must precede it.
This question asks which experiment can NEVER be in August. We need to check the rules to see which experiment is forbidden from being in the first month.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
The most relevant rule is Rule 4: "X must be performed in an earlier month than the month in which Z is performed."
- This means X must come before Z in the sequence of months. - If Z were in August (the earliest month), there would be no earlier month available for X to be performed in. - Therefore, Z cannot be in August.
To confirm the others are possible in August, we can refer to the valid schedule from question 1: - Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Y | Oct: P, Z - This shows R and X can be in August. We can also easily construct a schedule with P and Y in August. For example: - Aug: P, Y | Sep: R, X | Oct: T, Z. This is valid. So, P, R, X, and Y can all be in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
Z is the only experiment that cannot be performed in August due to the rule that X must precede it.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 3
If T is performed in September, which of the following must be true?
If T is performed in September, which of the following must be true?
Show Hint
For "must be true" questions, try to find a counterexample for each option. If you can build a single valid schedule where the statement is false, then it doesn't "must be true." The correct answer will be the one for which no counterexample is possible.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- P is performed in August.
- R is performed in September.
- X is performed in August.
- Y is performed in September.
- Z is performed in October.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is C
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is a conditional question. We add the new information (T is in September) to our rules and deduce what must necessarily follow.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: T is in September.
2. Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Since T is in September, X cannot be in September.
3. Rule 4 (X \textless Z): X must be performed in an earlier month than Z.
4. Combining these, X cannot be in September. If X were in October, there would be no later month for Z. Therefore, X must be in August.
5. Let's check the other options to see if they are necessarily true. - If X is in August and T is in September, then Z must be in October to satisfy X \textless Z. So (E) is also true. Let's re-read the question. - Ah, a subtlety. X must be in an earlier month. So if X is in August, Z can be in September or October. If X is in September, Z must be in October. - Let's re-do the deduction. 1. T is in September. 2. By Rule 3, X is not in September. 3. X cannot be in October, because then there would be no later month for Z (Rule 4). 4. Therefore, X must be in August. This makes option (C) a necessary truth.
6. Now let's re-evaluate (E) based on this. If X is in August, Z can be in September or October. If Z is in September, the September experiments would be T and Z. This is a possible scenario (e.g., Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Z | Oct: P, Y). Since Z does not HAVE to be in October, (E) is not a "must be true".
7. Let's check the other options. - (A) P can be in October. (See the valid scenario just constructed). - (B) R can be in August. (See the valid scenario). - (D) Y can be in August or October. (See the valid scenario).
Step 3: Final Answer:
Given that T is in September, X cannot be in September. To satisfy the condition that X is before Z, X must be in August.
This is a conditional question. We add the new information (T is in September) to our rules and deduce what must necessarily follow.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: T is in September.
2. Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Since T is in September, X cannot be in September.
3. Rule 4 (X \textless Z): X must be performed in an earlier month than Z.
4. Combining these, X cannot be in September. If X were in October, there would be no later month for Z. Therefore, X must be in August.
5. Let's check the other options to see if they are necessarily true. - If X is in August and T is in September, then Z must be in October to satisfy X \textless Z. So (E) is also true. Let's re-read the question. - Ah, a subtlety. X must be in an earlier month. So if X is in August, Z can be in September or October. If X is in September, Z must be in October. - Let's re-do the deduction. 1. T is in September. 2. By Rule 3, X is not in September. 3. X cannot be in October, because then there would be no later month for Z (Rule 4). 4. Therefore, X must be in August. This makes option (C) a necessary truth.
6. Now let's re-evaluate (E) based on this. If X is in August, Z can be in September or October. If Z is in September, the September experiments would be T and Z. This is a possible scenario (e.g., Aug: R, X | Sep: T, Z | Oct: P, Y). Since Z does not HAVE to be in October, (E) is not a "must be true".
7. Let's check the other options. - (A) P can be in October. (See the valid scenario just constructed). - (B) R can be in August. (See the valid scenario). - (D) Y can be in August or October. (See the valid scenario).
Step 3: Final Answer:
Given that T is in September, X cannot be in September. To satisfy the condition that X is before Z, X must be in August.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 4
If R is performed in the same month as Z, which of the following can be the pair of experiments performed in October?
If R is performed in the same month as Z, which of the following can be the pair of experiments performed in October?
Show Hint
When a new condition is added, first make all possible deductions from that condition combined with the original rules. This will often fix several elements in place, making the rest of the question much simpler.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- P and X
- P and Y
- R and Z
- T and Y
- X and Y
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is D
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is a conditional question. We add the condition that R and Z are in the same month and then see what possible pair can occupy the October slots.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: R and Z are in the same month.
2. Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): R must be in August or September. Therefore, the RZ pair must be in August or September.
3. Rule 4 (X \textless Z): X must be in an earlier month than Z. - If the RZ pair is in September, X must be in August. - If the RZ pair is in August, this violates Rule 4, as there is no earlier month for X. - Therefore, the RZ pair must be in September, and X must be in August.
4. Summary of fixed experiments: - August: X and one other experiment. - September: R and Z. - October: Two remaining experiments.
5. Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): T must be in September or October. September is full with R and Z, so T must be in October.
6. Conclusion about October: One of the experiments in October must be T. The other experiment will be one of the remaining "floater" experiments (P or Y). 7. Checking the options: - (A) P and X: X must be in August. - (B) P and Y: T must be in October. - (C) R and Z: This pair is in September. - (D) T and Y: This is a possible pairing for October. - (E) X and Y: X must be in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
Based on the deductions, the pair of experiments in October must include T. Option (D), T and Y, is a possible valid pair. A full valid schedule could be: Aug: X, P | Sep: R, Z | Oct: T, Y.
This is a conditional question. We add the condition that R and Z are in the same month and then see what possible pair can occupy the October slots.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: R and Z are in the same month.
2. Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): R must be in August or September. Therefore, the RZ pair must be in August or September.
3. Rule 4 (X \textless Z): X must be in an earlier month than Z. - If the RZ pair is in September, X must be in August. - If the RZ pair is in August, this violates Rule 4, as there is no earlier month for X. - Therefore, the RZ pair must be in September, and X must be in August.
4. Summary of fixed experiments: - August: X and one other experiment. - September: R and Z. - October: Two remaining experiments.
5. Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): T must be in September or October. September is full with R and Z, so T must be in October.
6. Conclusion about October: One of the experiments in October must be T. The other experiment will be one of the remaining "floater" experiments (P or Y). 7. Checking the options: - (A) P and X: X must be in August. - (B) P and Y: T must be in October. - (C) R and Z: This pair is in September. - (D) T and Y: This is a possible pairing for October. - (E) X and Y: X must be in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
Based on the deductions, the pair of experiments in October must include T. Option (D), T and Y, is a possible valid pair. A full valid schedule could be: Aug: X, P | Sep: R, Z | Oct: T, Y.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 5
If T is performed in the month before Z is performed, which of the following is a pair of experiments that can be performed in the same month as each other?
If T is performed in the month before Z is performed, which of the following is a pair of experiments that can be performed in the same month as each other?
Show Hint
For "could be true" questions, your goal is to construct one valid scenario that matches the option. Start with your main deductions, then try to place the pair from the option and see if you can complete the schedule without violating any rules.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- P and R
- P and Y
- R and Y
- R and Z
- X and Y
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is a conditional question. We add the new information "T is performed in the month before Z" and then determine which pair of experiments could possibly be scheduled together. This is a "could be true" question.
Initial Rules Recap: 1. R \(\in\) \{Aug, Sep\} 2. T \(\in\) \{Sep, Oct\} 3. T \(\neq\) X (in the same month) 4. X \textless Z (X is in an earlier month than Z)
Step 2: Applying the New Condition and Deducing the Schedule:
1. New Condition: T is in the month before Z (T \textless Z).
2. Deduction 1: From Rule 2, T is in Sep or Oct. If T were in Oct, there would be no later month for Z. Therefore, T must be in September, and Z must be in October.
3. Deduction 2: From Rule 4 (X \textless Z) and our finding that Z is in Oct, X can be in Aug or Sep. However, Rule 3 states T and X cannot be in the same month. Since T is in Sep, X cannot be in Sep. Therefore, X must be in August.
4. Summary of fixed experiments: The schedule must have X in August, T in September, and Z in October. This gives us the following frame: - August: {X, \_} - September: {T, \_} - October: {Z, \_}
5. Placing remaining experiments: The remaining experiments are P, R, and Y. They must fill the three empty slots. Rule 1 states R must be in Aug or Sep. - Scenario A: R is in August. The August pair is {X, R}. The remaining P and Y fill the slots in Sep and Oct. A possible valid schedule is Aug:{X,R}, Sep:{T,P}, Oct:{Z,Y}. - Scenario B: R is in September. The September pair is {T, R}. The remaining P and Y fill the slots in Aug and Oct. A possible valid schedule is Aug:{X,P}, Sep:{T,R}, Oct:{Z,Y}.
Step 3: Evaluating the Options:
We are looking for a pair that can be performed together. Let's try to build a valid schedule for one of the options. - (A) P and R: In both scenarios above, P and R are in different months. - (B) P and Y: In both scenarios above, P and Y are in different months. - (C) R and Y: In both scenarios above, R and Y are in different months. - (D) R and Z: Z is in October, R must be in August or September. They can't be together. - (E) X and Y: Let's see if this is possible. X must be in August. Let's try to place Y in August as well. - August: {X, Y} - We already deduced T is in Sep and Z is in Oct. - September: {T, \_} - October: {Z, \_} - The remaining experiments are P and R. From Rule 1, R must be in Aug or Sep. August is full, so R must be in September. The September pair becomes {T, R}. - The last experiment, P, must go in the last available slot in October. The October pair becomes {Z, P}. - The full schedule is: Aug:{X,Y}, Sep:{T,R}, Oct:{Z,P}. Let's check all rules. R is in Sep (ok). T is in Sep (ok). T is not with X (ok). X is before Z (ok). - This is a valid schedule. Therefore, X and Y can be performed together.
This is a conditional question. We add the new information "T is performed in the month before Z" and then determine which pair of experiments could possibly be scheduled together. This is a "could be true" question.
Initial Rules Recap: 1. R \(\in\) \{Aug, Sep\} 2. T \(\in\) \{Sep, Oct\} 3. T \(\neq\) X (in the same month) 4. X \textless Z (X is in an earlier month than Z)
Step 2: Applying the New Condition and Deducing the Schedule:
1. New Condition: T is in the month before Z (T \textless Z).
2. Deduction 1: From Rule 2, T is in Sep or Oct. If T were in Oct, there would be no later month for Z. Therefore, T must be in September, and Z must be in October.
3. Deduction 2: From Rule 4 (X \textless Z) and our finding that Z is in Oct, X can be in Aug or Sep. However, Rule 3 states T and X cannot be in the same month. Since T is in Sep, X cannot be in Sep. Therefore, X must be in August.
4. Summary of fixed experiments: The schedule must have X in August, T in September, and Z in October. This gives us the following frame: - August: {X, \_} - September: {T, \_} - October: {Z, \_}
5. Placing remaining experiments: The remaining experiments are P, R, and Y. They must fill the three empty slots. Rule 1 states R must be in Aug or Sep. - Scenario A: R is in August. The August pair is {X, R}. The remaining P and Y fill the slots in Sep and Oct. A possible valid schedule is Aug:{X,R}, Sep:{T,P}, Oct:{Z,Y}. - Scenario B: R is in September. The September pair is {T, R}. The remaining P and Y fill the slots in Aug and Oct. A possible valid schedule is Aug:{X,P}, Sep:{T,R}, Oct:{Z,Y}.
Step 3: Evaluating the Options:
We are looking for a pair that can be performed together. Let's try to build a valid schedule for one of the options. - (A) P and R: In both scenarios above, P and R are in different months. - (B) P and Y: In both scenarios above, P and Y are in different months. - (C) R and Y: In both scenarios above, R and Y are in different months. - (D) R and Z: Z is in October, R must be in August or September. They can't be together. - (E) X and Y: Let's see if this is possible. X must be in August. Let's try to place Y in August as well. - August: {X, Y} - We already deduced T is in Sep and Z is in Oct. - September: {T, \_} - October: {Z, \_} - The remaining experiments are P and R. From Rule 1, R must be in Aug or Sep. August is full, so R must be in September. The September pair becomes {T, R}. - The last experiment, P, must go in the last available slot in October. The October pair becomes {Z, P}. - The full schedule is: Aug:{X,Y}, Sep:{T,R}, Oct:{Z,P}. Let's check all rules. R is in Sep (ok). T is in Sep (ok). T is not with X (ok). X is before Z (ok). - This is a valid schedule. Therefore, X and Y can be performed together.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 6
If P is performed in the same month as Y, which of the following must be true?
If P is performed in the same month as Y, which of the following must be true?
Show Hint
For a "must be true" question, you must prove that the statement holds in every possible valid scenario that fits the condition. If you can find even one valid counterexample, the statement is not a "must be true." Systematically going through all cases is a reliable method.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- R is performed in the same month as T.
- R is performed in the same month as X.
- T is performed in August.
- X is performed in August.
- Y is performed in October.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is B
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is a conditional question asking what must be true if P and Y are scheduled in the same month. We must consider all possible months for the P-Y pair and see what conclusion holds in every case.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation by Cases:
Let's analyze the three possible months for the {P, Y} pair. The other four experiments are R, T, X, Z.
- Case 1: {P, Y are in August.} - August: {P, Y} - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): August is full, so R must be in September. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): T must be in September or October. - The remaining experiments to place are R, T, X, Z in Sep and Oct. We know R is in Sep. - If T is in September, then Sep would be {R, T}. The remaining two experiments, X and Z, would go in October. This violates Rule 4 (X \textless Z), as they would be in the same month. So T cannot be in September. - T must be in October. - The schedule so far: Aug:{P,Y}, Sep:{R,\_}, Oct:{T,\_}. The remaining experiments are X and Z. - To satisfy Rule 4 (X \textless Z), X must go in September and Z must go in October. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{P,Y}, Sep:{R,X}, Oct:{T,Z}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
- Case 2: {P, Y are in September.} - September: {P, Y} - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): September is full, so R must be in August. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): September is full, so T must be in October. - The remaining experiments are X and Z. The open slots are one in August and one in October. - To satisfy Rule 4 (X \textless Z), X must be in August and Z must be in October. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{R,X}, Sep:{P,Y}, Oct:{T,Z}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
- Case 3: {P, Y are in October.} - October: {P, Y} - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): October is full, so T must be in September. - Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Since T is in Sep, X cannot be in Sep. X must be in August. - The remaining experiments are R and Z. R must be in Aug or Sep (Rule 1). - If R were in September, Sep would be {T, R}. August would have X and Z. But this violates Rule 4 (X \textless Z). So R cannot be in September. - R must be in August. - The schedule so far: Aug:{X,R}, Sep:{T,\_}, Oct:{P,Y}. The only remaining experiment is Z, which must go in September. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{R,X}, Sep:{T,Z}, Oct:{P,Y}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
Step 3: Final Answer:
In all three possible cases, R and X must be performed in the same month. Therefore, statement (B) must be true.
This is a conditional question asking what must be true if P and Y are scheduled in the same month. We must consider all possible months for the P-Y pair and see what conclusion holds in every case.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation by Cases:
Let's analyze the three possible months for the {P, Y} pair. The other four experiments are R, T, X, Z.
- Case 1: {P, Y are in August.} - August: {P, Y} - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): August is full, so R must be in September. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): T must be in September or October. - The remaining experiments to place are R, T, X, Z in Sep and Oct. We know R is in Sep. - If T is in September, then Sep would be {R, T}. The remaining two experiments, X and Z, would go in October. This violates Rule 4 (X \textless Z), as they would be in the same month. So T cannot be in September. - T must be in October. - The schedule so far: Aug:{P,Y}, Sep:{R,\_}, Oct:{T,\_}. The remaining experiments are X and Z. - To satisfy Rule 4 (X \textless Z), X must go in September and Z must go in October. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{P,Y}, Sep:{R,X}, Oct:{T,Z}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
- Case 2: {P, Y are in September.} - September: {P, Y} - Rule 1 (R in Aug/Sep): September is full, so R must be in August. - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): September is full, so T must be in October. - The remaining experiments are X and Z. The open slots are one in August and one in October. - To satisfy Rule 4 (X \textless Z), X must be in August and Z must be in October. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{R,X}, Sep:{P,Y}, Oct:{T,Z}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
- Case 3: {P, Y are in October.} - October: {P, Y} - Rule 2 (T in Sep/Oct): October is full, so T must be in September. - Rule 3 (T \(\neq\) X): Since T is in Sep, X cannot be in Sep. X must be in August. - The remaining experiments are R and Z. R must be in Aug or Sep (Rule 1). - If R were in September, Sep would be {T, R}. August would have X and Z. But this violates Rule 4 (X \textless Z). So R cannot be in September. - R must be in August. - The schedule so far: Aug:{X,R}, Sep:{T,\_}, Oct:{P,Y}. The only remaining experiment is Z, which must go in September. - The only possible schedule is: Aug:{R,X}, Sep:{T,Z}, Oct:{P,Y}. In this case, R and X are in the same month.
Step 3: Final Answer:
In all three possible cases, R and X must be performed in the same month. Therefore, statement (B) must be true.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Question: 7
If X is performed in the month before Y is performed, which of the following must be true?
If X is performed in the month before Y is performed, which of the following must be true?
Show Hint
When faced with ordering constraints, a powerful technique is to test the placement of the most constrained variable (in this case, X). By proving that placing it in certain positions leads to a contradiction, you can deduce its required position.
Updated On: Oct 1, 2025
- P is performed in August.
- R is performed in September.
- T is performed in September.
- X is performed in August.
- Z is performed in October.
Hide Solution
Verified By Collegedunia
The Correct Option is D
Solution and Explanation
Step 1: Understanding the Concept:
This is another "must be true" question with a new conditional statement. We need to find a conclusion that is a necessary consequence of the new rule and the original rules.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: X is performed in the month before Y is performed (X \textless Y).
2. Original Rules Reminder: We also know from Rule 4 that X must be performed in a month before Z (X \textless Z).
3. Analysis of X's Position: Let's test the possible months for X. - Can X be in October? No, because it must come before both Y and Z, and there are no months after October. - Can X be in September? Let's assume X is in September. - If X is in September, then according to the new condition (X \textless Y) and the old rule (X \textless Z), both Y and Z must be performed in October. - This means the two experiments in October are {Y, Z}. - Now consider Rule 2: T must be in September or October. October is now full with {Y, Z}. So, T must be in September. - This would mean that the two experiments in September are {X, T}. - However, this violates Rule 3, which states that T and X cannot be performed in the same month. - This creates a contradiction. Therefore, the initial assumption that X can be in September must be false.
4. Conclusion: Since X cannot be in October and X cannot be in September, the only remaining possibility is that X must be performed in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
The combination of the new condition and the original rules forces X to be in August. Therefore, the statement "X is performed in August" must be true.
This is another "must be true" question with a new conditional statement. We need to find a conclusion that is a necessary consequence of the new rule and the original rules.
Step 2: Detailed Explanation:
1. New Condition: X is performed in the month before Y is performed (X \textless Y).
2. Original Rules Reminder: We also know from Rule 4 that X must be performed in a month before Z (X \textless Z).
3. Analysis of X's Position: Let's test the possible months for X. - Can X be in October? No, because it must come before both Y and Z, and there are no months after October. - Can X be in September? Let's assume X is in September. - If X is in September, then according to the new condition (X \textless Y) and the old rule (X \textless Z), both Y and Z must be performed in October. - This means the two experiments in October are {Y, Z}. - Now consider Rule 2: T must be in September or October. October is now full with {Y, Z}. So, T must be in September. - This would mean that the two experiments in September are {X, T}. - However, this violates Rule 3, which states that T and X cannot be performed in the same month. - This creates a contradiction. Therefore, the initial assumption that X can be in September must be false.
4. Conclusion: Since X cannot be in October and X cannot be in September, the only remaining possibility is that X must be performed in August.
Step 3: Final Answer:
The combination of the new condition and the original rules forces X to be in August. Therefore, the statement "X is performed in August" must be true.
Was this answer helpful?
0
0
Top Questions on Logical Reasoning
- Which one will replace the question mark?
- CUET (PG) - 2025
- General Management
- Logical Reasoning
Two players \( A \) and \( B \) are playing a game. Player \( A \) has two available actions \( a_1 \) and \( a_2 \). Player \( B \) has two available actions \( b_1 \) and \( b_2 \). The payoff matrix arising from their actions is presented below:
Let \( p \) be the probability that player \( A \) plays action \( a_1 \) in the mixed strategy Nash equilibrium of the game.
Then the value of p is (round off to one decimal place).- GATE XH-C1 - 2025
- General Aptitude
- Logical Reasoning
- Data Interpretation: The following table shows the number of students in five different colleges. Answer the questions based on the data. \[ \begin{array}{|c|c|} \hline \text{College} & \text{Number of Students} \\ \hline \text{A} & 1000 \\ \text{B} & 1500 \\ \text{C} & 1200 \\ \text{D} & 1300 \\ \text{E} & 900 \\ \hline \end{array} \] Question: What is the average number of students in all five colleges?
- VITEEE - 2025
- General Aptitude
- Logical Reasoning
Three friends, P, Q, and R, are solving a puzzle with statements:
(i) If P is a knight, Q is a knave.
(ii) If Q is a knight, R is a spy.
(iii) If R is a knight, P is a knave. Knights always tell the truth, knaves always lie, and spies sometimes tell the truth. If each friend is either a knight, knave, or spy, who is the knight?- CUET (UG) - 2025
- General Aptitude
- Logical Reasoning
- A is the brother of R. C is the mother of B. M is the sister of C. How is M related to B?
- VITEEE - 2025
- General Aptitude
- Logical Reasoning
View More Questions
Questions Asked in GRE exam
- Jean Valjean, the protagonist in Victor Hugo’s novel Les Misérables, spends the bulk of his lengthy _______ plotting a very clever set of revenge schemes, which he executes upon his escape.
- GRE - 2025
- Vocabulary
- Should we really care for the greatest actors of the past could we have them before us? Should we find them too different from our accent of thought, of feeling, of speech, in a thousand minute particulars which are of the essence of all three? Dr. Doran's long and interesting records of the triumphs of Garrick, and other less familiar, but in their day hardly less astonishing, players, do not relieve one of the doubt. Garrick himself, as sometimes happens with people who have been the subject of much anecdote and other conversation, here as elsewhere, bears no very distinct figure. One hardly sees the wood for the trees. On the other hand, the account of Betterton, "perhaps the greatest of English actors," is delightfully fresh. That intimate friend of Dryden, Tillatson, Pope, who executed a copy of the actor's portrait by Kneller which is still extant, was worthy of their friendship; his career brings out the best elements in stage life. The stage in these volumes presents itself indeed not merely as a mirror of life, but as an illustration of the utmost intensity of life, in the fortunes and characters of the players. Ups and downs, generosity, dark fates, the most delicate goodness, have nowhere been more prominent than in the private existence of those devoted to the public mimicry of men and women. Contact with the stage, almost throughout its history, presents itself as a kind of touchstone, to bring out the bizarrerie, the theatrical tricks and contrasts, of the actual world.
- GRE - 2025
- Reading Comprehension
- “Reviving the practice of using elements of popular music in classical composition, an approach that had been in hibernation in the United States during the 1960s, composer Philip Glass (born 1937) embraced the ethos of popular music in his compositions. Glass based two symphonies on music by rock musicians David Bowie and Brian Eno, but the symphonies' sound is distinctively his. Popular elements do not appear out of place in Glass's classical music, which from its early days has shared certain harmonies and rhythms with rock music. Yet this use of popular elements has not made Glass a composer of popular music. His music is not a version of popular music packaged to attract classical listeners; it is high art for listeners steeped in rock rather than the classics.
- GRE - 2025
- Reading Comprehension
- Called by some the “island that time forgot,” Madagascar is home to a vast array of unique, exotic creatures. One such animal is the aye-aye. First described by western science in 1782, it was initially categorized as a member of the order Rodentia. Further research then revealed that it was more closely related to the lemur, a member of the primate order. Since the aye-aye is so different from its fellow primates, however, it was given its own family: Daubentoniidae. The aye-aye has been listed as an endangered species and, as a result, the government of Madagascar has designated an island off the northeastern coast of Madagascar as a protected reserve for aye-ayes and other wildlife.
Long before Western science became enthralled with this nocturnal denizen of Madagascar’s jungles, the aye-aye had its own reputation with the local people. The aye aye is perhaps best known for its large, round eyes and long, extremely thin middle finger. These adaptations are quite sensible, allowing the aye-aye to see well at night and retrieve grubs, which are one of its primary food sources, from deep within hollow branches. However, the aye-aye’s striking appearance may end up causing its extinction. The people of Madagascar believe that the aye-aye is a type of spirit animal, and that its appearance is an omen of death. Whenever one is sighted, it is immediately killed. When combined with the loss of large swaths of jungle habitat, this practice may result in the loss of a superb .- GRE - 2025
- Reading Comprehension
- It has been suggested that long-term prisoners, on release from jail, be given a reasonable state pension to reduce the likelihood of their resorting to crime. Most people instinctively reject the suggestion as they feel it would be like rewarding criminal activity. The supporters of the prisoners' pension scheme have criticized those who reject this possibility, by claiming that for the critics...
Which of the following is the most logical completion of the sentence above?- GRE - 2025
- Critical Reasoning
View More Questions